Shrek the Mafia Game

[yvonnejambo]

Votes so far

Bunny -2

Sean -1

Stuart -1

Alim -1

Boof -1

[iantjambo]

Quite a few accusations being thrown around, based on not an awful lot.

 

Voting Bunny, because hes probably not a mason, seems a bit thin.

 

I'm always suspicious of people who throw others under the bus on day 1. When the person being lynched could easily be a key player for the town.

 

Therefore, for the time being, vote Sean

[Rudi Skacel]

Im going to

 

vote vlad

 

seemed very quick to try and jump

on Sean. Making a massive issue about nothing. 

[Vlad Magic]

6 minutes ago, Rudi Skacel said:

Im going to

 

vote vlad

 

seemed very quick to try and jump

on Sean. Making a massive issue about nothing. 

I would expect nothing less from you my friend 😍😍

[Dunks]

It's not the assassin we need to look for now, it's the saving votes that were cast yesterday - who was being saved and by whom.

 

My vote stays as is.

[Stuart McNeill]

the issue we're having is we're panicking about losing 2 masons so quickly.

 

Unfortunately for tonight it's a stab in the dark till tomorrow were we can then have ourselves a 4 man trust list.

 

Alongside this. We have a few quiet players hiding in the dark. We have players continuing to do silly actions and making themselves look like goons and really..

 

this seems to be the only option we currently have as we'd literally need to just pick someones name and lynch them

[Tenaciousdandy]

3 minutes ago, Stuart McNeill said:

the issue we're having is we're panicking about losing 2 masons so quickly.

 

Unfortunately for tonight it's a stab in the dark till tomorrow were we can then have ourselves a 4 man trust list.

 

Alongside this. We have a few quiet players hiding in the dark. We have players continuing to do silly actions and making themselves look like goons and really..

 

this seems to be the only option we currently have as we'd literally need to just pick someones name and lynch them

We'll have to be very careful with trust lists we can't have the cop or the mason outing themselves due to the charming turning becoming active from night 3, making any trust list redundant like when I was turned in the last game

[Stuart McNeill]

1 minute ago, Tenaciousdandy said:

We'll have to be very careful with trust lists we can't have the cop or the mason outing themselves due to the charming turning becoming active from night 3, making any trust list redundant like when I was turned in the last game

Ofcourse. I was meaning the last mason will have a 4 man trust list. 

 

Another dilemma we face is that currently we can't put a trust list out due to the fact we can have what happened last game where the goons could take someone from the trust list causing even more confusion 

[Stuart McNeill]

I feel comments like 'let's see the reaction this gets etc' 

 

Don't help as others won't be looking out for the people who you may be looking at and others may take what's happened differently causing mayhem 

[Tenaciousdandy]

1 minute ago, Stuart McNeill said:

Ofcourse. I was meaning the last mason will have a 4 man trust list. 

 

Another dilemma we face is that currently we can't put a trust list out due to the fact we can have what happened last game where the goons could take someone from the trust list causing even more confusion 

Yeah as long as the investigated player isn't lynched or night killed it will at least help the mason narrow down the suspect list for themshelves 

[Riddley Walker]

4 minutes ago, Stuart McNeill said:

I feel comments like 'let's see the reaction this gets etc' 

 

Don't help as others won't be looking out for the people who you may be looking at and others may take what's happened differently causing mayhem 

 

Agree with this. Also, unless the goon/Mason team are desperate near deadline time there's not going to be an immediate reaction as it would be too obvious. 

[Rudi Skacel]

2 hours ago, Seats said:

I jumped on bunny because dawn voted for bunny. Unlikely to vote for another mason, so seems a safe(ish) vote. Your reaction was a bit defensive for no obvious reason, hence why i'm a bit suspicious. I have nothing else to go on.

 

1 hour ago, AlimOzturk said:

Vote bunny 

 

seats has a solid point. Dawnrazor voted him and unless we are going through the whole peaky saga killing his fellow mason then it is safe to assume bunny isn’t the other mason. Could of course be the cop but there isn’t much else to go on. 

just a thought but why are you basing your votes on Bunny based on nonsense? Dawnrazor didnt vote for bunny. 

[Tenaciousdandy]

Just now, Rudi Skacel said:

 

just a thought but why are you basing your votes on Bunny based on nonsense? Dawnrazor didnt vote for bunny. 

And why not target shapes as she put dawn into a tie 

[Seats]

5 minutes ago, Rudi Skacel said:

 

just a thought but why are you basing your votes on Bunny based on nonsense? Dawnrazor didnt vote for bunny. 

No but peaky did and bunny voted for peaky, but never batted an eyelid when i said dawn 🤔

[Bunny Munro]

4 minutes ago, Seats said:

No but peaky did and bunny voted for peaky, but never batted an eyelid when i said dawn 🤔

You said Dawn had voted for me. I assumed you were right. 

Didn't bother checking.

 

It was a vote based on very little due to it being day 1. 

[Rudi Skacel]

12 minutes ago, Tenaciousdandy said:

And why not target shapes as she put dawn into a tie 

im not targetting anyone. Im only asking the question as to why. 

[Tenaciousdandy]

4 minutes ago, Bunny Munro said:

You said Dawn had voted for me. I assumed you were right. 

Didn't bother checking.

 

It was a vote based on very little due to it being day 1. 

Dawn voted Sheldon on day 1

[Tenaciousdandy]

1 minute ago, Rudi Skacel said:

im not targetting anyone. Im only asking the question as to why. 

Sorry I meant seats not you 

[jambosean75]

i think this is right

 

1. Stuart McNeill								1
2. Boof								1
3. AlimOzturk	bunny							1
8. Rudi Skacel	vlad
9. Bunny Munro								2
10. Seats	bunny
11. Vlad Magic	sean	unvote						1
12. JamboSean	stuart							1
13. Dr. Sheldon Cooper	alim
14. Prince Buaben
15. Riddley Walker
16. Shapes
17. Morgaro Gomis
18. Tenaciousdandy
19. Iantjambo	sean
20. Dunks	ian	boof
								7

[Bunny Munro]

1 minute ago, Tenaciousdandy said:

Sorry I meant seats not you 

No bother.

[jambosean75]

1 hour ago, iantjambo said:

Quite a few accusations being thrown around, based on not an awful lot.

 

Voting Bunny, because hes probably not a mason, seems a bit thin.

 

I'm always suspicious of people who throw others under the bus on day 1. When the person being lynched could easily be a key player for the town.

 

Therefore, for the time being, vote Sean

 

or it could be a goon

 

mass ties are a cop out, it's like people are trying to avoid making a choice

[Tenaciousdandy]

1 minute ago, Bunny Munro said:

No bother.

I was replying to rudi lol I did reply to you confirming Dawn voted Sheldon not you tho 

[Bunny Munro]

4 minutes ago, Tenaciousdandy said:

I was replying to rudi lol I did reply to you confirming Dawn voted Sheldon not you tho 

Sorry, that's what happens when I try and Mafia and work at the same time 😂

[Bunny Munro]

9 minutes ago, jambosean75 said:

 

or it could be a goon

 

mass ties are a cop out, it's like people are trying to avoid making a choice

I agree it's is a cop out. Noone wants to make a decision incase it's wrong and they're held accountable for it.

 

In saying that, we can't rule out Andy being pushed ahead to try and protect someone, and we know it wasn't a mason.

[jambosean75]

1 minute ago, Bunny Munro said:

I agree it's is a cop out. Noone wants to make a decision incase it's wrong and they're held accountable for it.

 

In saying that, we can't rule out Andy being pushed ahead to try and protect someone, and we know it wasn't a mason.

 

i only picked andy as he seemed quieter than usual

 

i really wanted peaky to be in the tie so i could lynch him and shout there's ya ****ing medicine

 

petty i know but it would have been funny until we found out he was a mason

 

then i would definitely have gotten lynched today

[Bunny Munro]

1 minute ago, jambosean75 said:

 

i only picked andy as he seemed quieter than usual

 

i really wanted peaky to be in the tie so i could lynch him and shout there's ya ****ing medicine

 

petty i know but it would have been funny until we found out he was a mason

 

then i would definitely have gotten lynched today

I don't blame you, but I also don't blame those pointing fingers. 

[iantjambo]

22 minutes ago, jambosean75 said:

 

or it could be a goon

 

mass ties are a cop out, it's like people are trying to avoid making a choice

There are more good roled players than there are goons. Doing something like that on day 1 means you’re far more likely to hit a good player than a goon. 

[Stuart McNeill]

  

  

On 17/01/2021 at 14:44, Bunny Munro said:

vote peaky

just a placeholder vote for now, will change if anything comes up.

Bunny voted Peaky

 

Peaky replied with

 

On 17/01/2021 at 15:38, Peakybunnet said:

 

Just noticed this, will vote for you as haven't got a scooby about anybody this game.

 

Vote Bunny

 

Its simply two people being happy to vote each other to get through to day 2. Pointless focusing on the fact that Bunny ha voted him even though he died at night.

 

 

------

 

 

 

the other situation started around the time Myself, Boof and Prince were tied each on 2 points each.

 

Boof took Buaben out of the tie due to him becoming active.

21 hours ago, Boof said:

Unvote Prince Buaben

 

since he's here now, until I can get a decent read of the thread. 

 

Anybody looking like being modkilled?

 

20 hours ago, jambosean75 said:

lets see what happens if i 

 

unvote stuart

With sean then deciding to take me out the vote. Leaving Sheldon in the lead.

20 hours ago, Dr. Sheldon Cooper said:

Realised I hadn't unvoted Alim 😂

 

Unvote Alim

 

Vote Dandy

Ofcourse Sheldon decides to shake some stuff up by voting dandy and putting them in a tie together.

Then shapes decides to throw dawn in the mix probably as revenge, which tbf, I don't blame her.

 

20 hours ago, Peakybunnet said:

Am tempted to put somebody else on 2, but its like finding a needle in a haystack just now. 

and peaky hoping to stick someone else on to 2 but decided against it.

20 hours ago, jambosean75 said:

vote andy

 

make it interesting

with sean getting there final blow.

 

So who looks bad coming out of this.

 

Shapes, Sean, Sheldon.

 

Shapes obviously wanted revenge.

Sheldon put dandy in a tie.

Sean felt andy was quieter. (did he say he had work?)

 

 

As it seems it's safe to say that these players are probably not working together but apart from that Sean putting andy right out in the front its not overly suspicious.

 

 

I hope I've not missed anything crucial.

[Prince Buaben]

what a day. not had a chance to read will get that on my break.

 

anyone who doesn't already. don't have kids especially through a pandemic 

[Stuart McNeill]

notably low posters

 

Prince Buaben

Rudi

 

only people with fewer Post count is those who are dead.

 

Still early on in the day

 

 

 

[Riddley Walker]

11 minutes ago, Prince Buaben said:

what a day. not had a chance to read will get that on my break.

 

anyone who doesn't already. don't have kids especially through a pandemic 

 

Homeschooling and trying to work at the same time. What a bundle of joy.

[Dunks]

13 minutes ago, Stuart McNeill said:

notably low posters

 

Prince Buaben

Rudi

 

only people with fewer Post count is those who are dead.

 

Still early on in the day

 

 

 

 

I forgot Prince was even playing. Goon or last mason in hiding 

[Prince Buaben]

12 minutes ago, Riddley Walker said:

 

Homeschooling and trying to work at the same time. What a bundle of joy.

 

 

I'm lucky I have to go out to work for peace in the afternoon evenings. 

 

let's get read up on this..

[Prince Buaben]

1 minute ago, Dunks said:

 

I forgot Prince was even playing. Goon or last mason in hiding 

 

Neither. unfortunately 

[Vlad Magic]

26 minutes ago, Stuart McNeill said:

  

  

Bunny voted Peaky

 

Peaky replied with

 

 

Its simply two people being happy to vote each other to get through to day 2. Pointless focusing on the fact that Bunny ha voted him even though he died at night.

 

 

------

 

 

 

the other situation started around the time Myself, Boof and Prince were tied each on 2 points each.

 

Boof took Buaben out of the tie due to him becoming active.

 

With sean then deciding to take me out the vote. Leaving Sheldon in the lead.

Ofcourse Sheldon decides to shake some stuff up by voting dandy and putting them in a tie together.

Then shapes decides to throw dawn in the mix probably as revenge, which tbf, I don't blame her.

 

and peaky hoping to stick someone else on to 2 but decided against it.

with sean getting there final blow.

 

So who looks bad coming out of this.

 

Shapes, Sean, Sheldon.

 

Shapes obviously wanted revenge.

Sheldon put dandy in a tie.

Sean felt andy was quieter. (did he say he had work?)

 

 

As it seems it's safe to say that these players are probably not working together but apart from that Sean putting andy right out in the front its not overly suspicious.

 

 

I hope I've not missed anything crucial.

Thank you for dissecting in great detail what was a very confusing first day vote.

 

Was Andy the bait after last game with the masons hoping the Goons would bite? Ballsy early move if so?

 

No idea what Peaky did. Must have been blind luck?

 

Assassin seriously? Grab a Viagra. Will stop you shooting early.

[Riddley Walker]

I'm genuinely flummoxed as to who to give my vote to. It wouldn't be the end of the world if we hit a townie, but we have a mason, doc and cop who have no back up who could easily be on the wrong end of a lynch if we just dive in.

 

I'm equally wary about putting my vote onto the quiet players, as although there's most likely a goon in there there's also a good chance the doc or cop is in there trying to keep a low profile.

 

We still have 4 goons left, which is 25 percent of the remainig players if I'm not mistaken. Need to get one the next lynch or two and hope the assassin gets on board. If we lose another 3 players without hitting a goon we're closing in on a third of the remaining players being a goon and we're struggling.

 

[Tenaciousdandy]

2 minutes ago, Vlad Magic said:

Thank you for dissecting in great detail what was a very confusing first day vote.

 

Was Andy the bait after last game with the masons hoping the Goons would bite? Ballsy early move if so?

 

No idea what Peaky did. Must have been blind luck?

 

Assassin seriously? Grab a Viagra. Will stop you shooting early.

Read peakys post carefully, I think he outed himself as a mason on day fecking one with no pressure on him either 

[Vlad Magic]

25 minutes ago, Tenaciousdandy said:

Read peakys post carefully, I think he outed himself as a mason on day fecking one with no pressure on him either 

Why though?

 

That would be ridiculous surely?

[Rudi Skacel]

50 minutes ago, Stuart McNeill said:

notably low posters

 

Prince Buaben

Rudi

 

only people with fewer Post count is those who are dead.

 

Still early on in the day

 

 

 

Can you post the full post count please?

[Tenaciousdandy]

1 minute ago, Vlad Magic said:

Why though?

 

That would be ridiculous surely?

I have no idea, I could be wrong, as you say it would be ridiculous

[Stuart McNeill]

18 minutes ago, Rudi Skacel said:

Can you post the full post count please?

TenaciousDandy	44
JamboSean	31
Stuart	28
Seats	21
BunnyMunro	19
Dr. Sheldon	18
Riddley	18
Boof	16
Shapes	16
Vladmagic	16
Dunks	15
Morgaro Gomis	15
Ian	14
Alim	13
Dawnrazor	12
Rudiskacel	10
Prince Buaben	9
Andy	8
Peaky	5

 

 

I do my best to keep this 100% correct.

[Vlad Magic]

1 minute ago, Stuart McNeill said:

 

TenaciousDandy	44
JamboSean	31
Stuart	28
Seats	21
BunnyMunro	19
Dr. Sheldon	18
Riddley	18
Boof	16
Shapes	16
Vladmagic	16
Dunks	15
Morgaro Gomis	15
Ian	14
Alim	13
Dawnrazor	12
Rudiskacel	10
Prince Buaben	9
Andy	8
Peaky	5

 

 

I do my best to keep this 100% correct.

 

Get your post count up or it’s looking like you are ****ed!!

[Rudi Skacel]

1 minute ago, Stuart McNeill said:

 

TenaciousDandy	44
JamboSean	31
Stuart	28
Seats	21
BunnyMunro	19
Dr. Sheldon	18
Riddley	18
Boof	16
Shapes	16
Vladmagic	16
Dunks	15
Morgaro Gomis	15
Ian	14
Alim	13
Dawnrazor	12
Rudiskacel	10
Prince Buaben	9
Andy	8
Peaky	5

 

 

I do my best to keep this 100% correct.

So in the grand scheme of things, its not all that much of a tell tale really. 
 

perhaps we could all be like others and split up one post into 3?

[Dr. Sheldon Cooper]

51 minutes ago, Tenaciousdandy said:

Read peakys post carefully, I think he outed himself as a mason on day fecking one with no pressure on him either 

 

His very first post? I can't see what you see, nobody would do that surely.

[Stuart McNeill]

9 minutes ago, Vlad Magic said:

 

Get your post count up or it’s looking like you are ****ed!!

 

9 minutes ago, Rudi Skacel said:

So in the grand scheme of things, its not all that much of a tell tale really. 
 

perhaps we could all be like others and split up one post into 3?

 

Tbh, I was keeping it counted mostly because the "if you're quiet you must be a goon theory that usually crops up" It'd be interesting to see who brings it up and who they're blaming.

 

There mostly isn't anything in post count like you say but I'm here just trying to provide info for the town.

 

1. Stuart McNeill
2. Boof
3. AlimOzturk	bunny
4. Dawnrazor
6. Andy Nics
7. Peakybunnet
8. Rudi Skacel	Vlad
9. Bunny Munro
10. Seats	Bunny
11. Vlad Magic	Sean	unvote
12. JamboSean	Stuart
13. Dr. Sheldon Cooper	Alim
14. Prince Buaben
15. Riddley Walker
16. Shapes
17. Morgaro Gomis
18. Tenaciousdandy
19. Iantjambo	Sean
20. Dunks	Ian	boof

 

Bunny - 2 (alim, Sheldon)

Vlad - 1 (Rudi)

Stuart - 1 (Sean)

Alim - 1 (Sheldon)

Sean - 1 (Ian)

Boof - 1 (dunks)

 

5 minutes ago, Dr. Sheldon Cooper said:

 

His very first post? I can't see what you see, nobody would do that surely.

Remember two of them died during the night.

 

I don't think he'd be that obvious

Edited January 18, 2021 by Stuart McNeill

[Bunny Munro]

5 minutes ago, Dr. Sheldon Cooper said:

 

His very first post? I can't see what you see, nobody would do that surely.

I'm not sure what he's referring to either.

Either I'm being dense or its really cryptic.

[Bunny Munro]

The problem with the 'If you're quiet you're a goon' is by losing two masons on night 1, the other mason must stay out of the firing squad somehow.

[AlimOzturk]

Anyone got a vote count?

[Boof]

Evening all. No - not an attempt at claiming cop.

 

Been full on at work today so hardly got a look.

 

Back in a bit once I've had a good read of it all.

 

 

[AlimOzturk]

Unvote bunny