Scottish independence and devolution superthread

[JudyJudyJudy]

17 minutes ago, Gundermann said:

Asserting that sex is a biological fact or that it is not changed just by virtue of the gender by which someone chooses to identify is not and never can be a hate crime under this legislation.”

Yes i am aware of that. However if say a person writes this or says this after April 1st a person may be offended by this and contact the police. Thats the concerning issue. 

[JudyJudyJudy]

8 minutes ago, stevie said:

Last few pages have “at last” been pretty *** good and definitely funny.Perhaps the Natz have a sense of humour after all,who knew 👍

Def not. Thats a feature they have with Sturgeon et al. Zero sense of humour. Zero. Its an awful liability in life. 

[Lord Montpelier]

2 minutes ago, JudyJudyJudy said:

Def not. Thats a feature they have with Sturgeon et al. Zero sense of humour. Zero. Its an awful liability in life. 

To be fair one of them went off on one questioning my mental state recently, I found that funny. 

[JudyJudyJudy]

22 minutes ago, Gundermann said:

 

By the Daily Mail and Dross? Ok then...

 

https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2024/mar/21/humza-yousaf-criticises-disinformation-over-new-scottish-hate-law

 

 

and how do you prove someone is " stirring up hatred " ?  

[Konrad von Carstein]

1 minute ago, JudyJudyJudy said:

Def not. Thats a feature they have with Sturgeon et al. Zero sense of humour. Zero. Its an awful liability in life. 

Bwahahahahaha.... You're never exactly ooze humour.

Ever.

Sarcasm, pissyness and lack of self awareness, those you have in abundance.

 

[JudyJudyJudy]

5 minutes ago, Konrad von Carstein said:

Bwahahahahaha.... You're never exactly ooze humour.

Ever.

Sarcasm, pissyness and lack of self awareness, those you have in abundance.

 

Your dull as dishwater dear,. dreary Sorry. 

[JudyJudyJudy]

30 minutes ago, Gundermann said:

 

By the Daily Mail and Dross? Ok then...

 

https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2024/mar/21/humza-yousaf-criticises-disinformation-over-new-scottish-hate-law

 

 

Actually appreciate you are at least discussing some of the finer issues of this legilslation unlike others on this who are just going for my jugular. 

[Lord Montpelier]

33 minutes ago, XB52 said:

Thank you. Always happy to have my Scottish nationalist credentials cemented by the British nationalists

I always had you down as an Alba leaning nationalist for some reason.

 

Who as far as I can tell from the like of Neale Hanvey have little support for this hate crime pish

[Japan Jambo]

3 hours ago, Dawnrazor said:

We need more settlers in England.

 

Quite agree, I view it as a cultural exchange. 

 

2 hours ago, Dawnrazor said:

To be fair Konnie, I've better than that cleaning the dungeon.

 

TBF she's on light duties only given her condition.

[stevie]

Also,the Green Party seem like a right hoot.Their annual shindig must be quite the thing.

[JudyJudyJudy]

3 minutes ago, stevie said:

Also,the Green Party seem like a right hoot.Their annual shindig must be quite the thing.

Imagine that? everyone minding their ps and qs scared to get pished in case they really say what they are thinking

 

[Dawnrazor]

11 minutes ago, Japan Jambo said:

 

 

 

TBF she's on light duties only given her condition.

Not here she won't!

[stevie]

1 hour ago, JudyJudyJudy said:

Imagine that? everyone minding their ps and qs scared to get pished in case they really say what they are thinking

 

Id imagine there’s absolutely no alcohol at a Green shindig JJJ

Probably sat hugging each other and having a right good cry.

[henrysmithsgloves]

1 hour ago, JudyJudyJudy said:

and how do you prove someone is " stirring up hatred " ?  

Catch them in the act, using this utensil 😂

Exhibit A..

[Konrad von Carstein]

1 hour ago, JudyJudyJudy said:

Your dull as dishwater dear,. dreary Sorry. 

Like I said lack of self awareness, you're tedious and get all your nonsense (which you don't check) from the express and some Hibs fud on twitter.

 

[JudyJudyJudy]

8 minutes ago, Konrad von Carstein said:

Like I said lack of self awareness, you're tedious and get all your nonsense (which you don't check) from the express and some Hibs fud on twitter.

 

Bore off. 

[JudyJudyJudy]

28 minutes ago, stevie said:

Id imagine there’s absolutely no alcohol at a Green shindig JJJ

Probably sat hugging each other and having a right good cry.

Aye itll be chai tea and touchy feely hugs and emotions all over the place. count me out.  

[JudyJudyJudy]

24 minutes ago, henrysmithsgloves said:

Catch them in the act, using this utensil 😂

Exhibit A..

Thats no big enough for some on this  

[henrysmithsgloves]

1 hour ago, JudyJudyJudy said:

Thats no big enough for some on this  

 

[henrysmithsgloves]

18 minutes ago, Jim_Duncan said:

When the lad suggested spooning, he had no idea it would lead to this nonsense. 

😳😂

[been here before]

1 hour ago, Konrad von Carstein said:

Like I said lack of self awareness, you're tedious and get all your nonsense (which you don't check) from the express and some Hibs fud on twitter.

 

 

He's also done a couple of awareness courses at work.

[Thunder and Lightning]

12 hours ago, JudyJudyJudy said:

Dp

Mucky *******. 

[Thunder and Lightning]

6 hours ago, Dawnrazor said:

 

Tough wank. 

[Dawnrazor]

4 minutes ago, Thunder and Lightning said:

Tough wank. 

Probably not for eachother ironically, but aye, I agree.

[OTT]

6 hours ago, Lord Montpelier said:

Can't say in a massive tory fan right now but I'd vote for Penny just to see her get the opportunity to lampoon thick nationalists on a more regular basis

 

I'm a nationalist, but not an SNP fan. 

 

I find Mordaunts constant aggression towards the SNP pretty contrived and boring TBH. Its basically just low level theatre. Can tell a lot of work goes in, not on substantive answers but building  "Penny crushes the SNP" montages. She knows exactly what witty retorts the SNP are getting today before she even steps in the chamber. Its not something I can warm to. 

 

I think there is a good chance she could succeed Sunak though. Despite not particularly liking her, I think she could appeal to middle England - Sunak seems weak, not a strong leader with clear vision - Mordaunt or even Kemi Badenoch both seem much stronger characters that could offer the Tory's a glimmer of hope. With Starmer fumbling the bag at every turn, if the Tories can quickly get their house in order I think Mordaunt against Starmer is a genuine contest that England will struggle with. Starmer has given the young absolutely nothing to vote for, and the old just need a reason to revert back to Tory (I'm generalising for the sake of my point). If I was running the Tory campaign, the question I would want plastered across every bus stop up and down the country would be "What Does Keir Starmer even stand for?" - Blunt answer is absolutely nothing. I don't even think the guy would feel comfortable telling you the time less he risks offence!

 

TBH I don't want to see Starmer win, because all he's done is taken being a tory and added water. I don't want the Labour party to think that is a viable election strategy. They need to offer something different. The prospect of letting war dog spineless creeps like Douglas Alexander back into politics kills me inside. Hopefully see a complete rejection of Starmers characterless brand of politics. 

[Thunder and Lightning]

19 minutes ago, Dawnrazor said:

Probably not for eachother ironically, but aye, I agree.

😂 

[Cranston]

20 minutes ago, OTT said:

 

I'm a nationalist, but not an SNP fan. 

 

I find Mordaunts constant aggression towards the SNP pretty contrived and boring TBH. Its basically just low level theatre. Can tell a lot of work goes in, not on substantive answers but building  "Penny crushes the SNP" montages. She knows exactly what witty retorts the SNP are getting today before she even steps in the chamber. Its not something I can warm to. 

 

I think there is a good chance she could succeed Sunak though. Despite not particularly liking her, I think she could appeal to middle England - Sunak seems weak, not a strong leader with clear vision - Mordaunt or even Kemi Badenoch both seem much stronger characters that could offer the Tory's a glimmer of hope. With Starmer fumbling the bag at every turn, if the Tories can quickly get their house in order I think Mordaunt against Starmer is a genuine contest that England will struggle with. Starmer has given the young absolutely nothing to vote for, and the old just need a reason to revert back to Tory (I'm generalising for the sake of my point). If I was running the Tory campaign, the question I would want plastered across every bus stop up and down the country would be "What Does Keir Starmer even stand for?" - Blunt answer is absolutely nothing. I don't even think the guy would feel comfortable telling you the time less he risks offence!

 

TBH I don't want to see Starmer win, because all he's done is taken being a tory and added water. I don't want the Labour party to think that is a viable election strategy. They need to offer something different. The prospect of letting war dog spineless creeps like Douglas Alexander back into politics kills me inside. Hopefully see a complete rejection of Starmers characterless brand of politics. 

Good post. 

What does a jeremy corbyn pupil, marxist, north london elitist, who is along with his front bench, pretending to be born again fandans of Thatcher have in common with Scotland?

 

Answers on a postcard please. 

 

Edited March 21 by Cranston

[JudyJudyJudy]

1 hour ago, Thunder and Lightning said:

Mucky *******. 

😎

[Libertarian]

I have campaigned for independence all my adult life but when I look at the modern SNP I despair at what they have become, incompetence, nepotism and corruption. On top of all that we are now living in a country where ordinary Scots have never been more policed and regulated than now (the Hate Crime Bill is only the most recent example of this). I still support independence and believe that the economic powers that will come with independence will help to stop the increasing decline in our country, however independence will never be achieved through the SNP.

[TallPaul]

1 minute ago, Libertarian said:

I have campaigned for independence all my adult life but when I look at the modern SNP I despair at what they have become, incompetence, nepotism and corruption. On top of all that we are now living in a country where ordinary Scots have never been more policed and regulated than now (the Hate Crime Bill is only the most recent example of this). I still support independence and believe that the economic powers that will come with independence will help to stop the increasing decline in our country, however independence will never be achieved through the SNP.

Who do you plan to vote for next election? Unless if course you decide to abstain.

[Libertarian]

Just now, TallPaul said:

Who do you plan to vote for next election? Unless if course you decide to abstain.

For the first time in my life I will probably abstain although I would vote Alba, Scottish Independence Party or Scottish Libertarian Party if they stand in my constituency. I certainly can't vote for any unionist party and the SNP have betrayed the trust placed in them by the Scottish electorate and are now part of the problem.

[BlueRiver]

13 hours ago, Cranston said:

Good post. 

What does a jeremy corbyn pupil, marxist, north london elitist, who is along with his front bench, pretending to be born again fandans of Thatcher have in common with Scotland?

 

Answers on a postcard please. 

 

 

Probably about the same as a humble crofter banker has in common with me and a lot of other Scots to be fair...

 

Or a wee daftie that done a part time stint in a chippie before heading to Westminster? 

 

Or am I meant to feel a natural affinity to these tubes just because we share a nationality? 

[BlueRiver]

Saying that I'm sure I and lots of other Scots have plenty in common with privately educated Humza Yousef who's entire career consists of...politics...

 

Now that's a man of the Scottish people right there. 

 

 

[Libertarian]

2 minutes ago, BlueRiver said:

Saying that I'm sure I and lots of other Scots have plenty in common with privately educated Humza Yousef who's entire career consists of...politics...

 

Now that's a man of the Scottish people right there. 

 

 

Exactly the same could be said of Sarwar. They even went to the same private school 

[BlueRiver]

Just now, Libertarian said:

Exactly the same could be said of Sarwar. They even went to the same private school 

 

It could indeed. 

 

Are we in an odd situation where the Tory is the only leader of a main party at Holyrood that wasn't privately educated? 😂

[Australis]

58 minutes ago, Libertarian said:

I have campaigned for independence all my adult life but when I look at the modern SNP I despair at what they have become, incompetence, nepotism and corruption. On top of all that we are now living in a country where ordinary Scots have never been more policed and regulated than now (the Hate Crime Bill is only the most recent example of this). I still support independence and believe that the economic powers that will come with independence will help to stop the increasing decline in our country, however independence will never be achieved through the SNP.

Everything they said other political parties have, but they would be different.

 

Can't wait until their first bad election result and the SNP members and voters turn on Yousaf.

 

Then he plays the race card.

Rats in a sack.

 

[micole]

56 minutes ago, Libertarian said:

For the first time in my life I will probably abstain although I would vote Alba, Scottish Independence Party or Scottish Libertarian Party if they stand in my constituency. I certainly can't vote for any unionist party and the SNP have betrayed the trust placed in them by the Scottish electorate and are now part of the problem.

Pretty much where I am at. Really at a stage where I might not even vote, and that does not sit well with me.....🤷‍♂️

Edited March 22 by micole

[Libertarian]

2 minutes ago, BlueRiver said:

 

It could indeed. 

 

Are we in an odd situation where the Tory is the only leader of a main party at Holyrood that wasn't privately educated? 😂

We are in a position where there is no real choice between Labour & Tory. They have morphed into the same uni party as have the SNP who having become part of the British establishment don't really want any radical change. Yet there has never been more need for radical change. Just look at the increase in poverty, we even have decreasing life expectancy for crying out loud.

[Libertarian]

1 minute ago, Australis said:

Everything they said other political parties have, but they would be different.

 

Can't wait until their first bad election result and the SNP members and voters turn on Yousaf.

 

Then he plays the race card.

Rats in a sack.

 

The SNP are are in for an absolute pasting at the next British election. They don't even appear to be aware about how unpopular they actually are. I honestly think that they could be finished.

[BlueRiver]

Just now, Libertarian said:

We are in a position where there is no real choice between Labour & Tory. They have morphed into the same uni party as have the SNP who having become part of the British establishment don't really want any radical change. Yet there has never been more need for radical change. Just look at the increase in poverty, we even have decreasing life expectancy for crying out loud.

 

So...

 

Is that an aye Ross is the only one that isn't privately educated? 

 

Also define "radical change" please. It can mean a hundred different things to a hundred different people. Which is curiously quite often why it gets ****ing nowhere. 

 

[Australis]

1 hour ago, Libertarian said:

The SNP are are in for an absolute pasting at the next British election. They don't even appear to be aware about how unpopular they actually are. I honestly think that they could be finished.

I would love them to tell the truth about what people are telling them on the doorsteps.

 

Once so many of them get kicked out they will turn on Humza, so quickly.

 

Then Humza tells the SNP members and Scottish public they are all racist After he and his party are humiliated.

 

 

[Japan Jambo]

1 hour ago, Libertarian said:

The SNP are are in for an absolute pasting at the next British election. They don't even appear to be aware about how unpopular they actually are. I honestly think that they could be finished.

 

That's hubris surely? I'd have thought they have a decent chance to be his majesty's loyal opposition... 

[Cranston]

5 hours ago, Libertarian said:

I have campaigned for independence all my adult life but when I look at the modern SNP I despair at what they have become, incompetence, nepotism and corruption. On top of all that we are now living in a country where ordinary Scots have never been more policed and regulated than now (the Hate Crime Bill is only the most recent example of this). I still support independence and believe that the economic powers that will come with independence will help to stop the increasing decline in our country, however independence will never be achieved through the SNP.

The Snp unfortunately, took the wrong course of policy towards the UK. Instead of making Scotland a success story, and demonstrating what could be, they did the complete opposite. Their main policy seems to have been deliberate failure, and blame the UK government for all their ills. Salmond and Sturgeon should have very easily completed the dream outcome, but look at them both now. Their reputations in tatters, their party facing terminal decline. A shambles.

[AyrJambo]

On 21/03/2024 at 07:57, il Duce McTarkin said:

 

Being English, would you class me and my family as 'occupiers'?

 

 

Same question to you, Ayr. Occupiers or citizens?

 

I have no issue with you, your family, anyone from England or indeed anywhere else who chooses to come here to live/work/rest/ or otherwise lead their life
I have in the past chosen to live and work abroad and I would react the way you have if someone had called me a "settler" or "occupier" so apologies for any offence but I was not referring to any individual people

It's not about individuals it's about the inherent imbalance built in to a union between two countries where one has a population over 10 times the size of the other

 

Population of the UK and its constituent countries, mid-2021

 

UK        67,026,000    
England        56,536,000    
Wales        3,105,000    
Northern Ireland    1,905,000    
Scotland        5,480,000 

 

If 10% of the Scottish population moved to England they would make up around 0.9% of the population in England - very easily assimilated
If 10% of the English population moved to Scotland they would make up around a whopping 103% of the populattion in Scotland - not so easily assimilated

 

The 2011 census shows that the largest group of migrants living in Scotland was around 500,000 people born in England and Wales and based on recent trends will probably exceed 750,000 by now - that is well over 10% of the population

Additionally these migrants tend to be professionals - doctors, academics, civil servants and teachers - so policy-shapers and opinion formers
For example in 2018 33% of all teachers across Scotland were from England

 

I'm not arguing that only Scots should be allowed to live and work in Scotland or that only Scots should be able to teach in Scotland but the levels of migration into Scotland from one other country, England, are a form of de facto colonisation

[JudyJudyJudy]

11 minutes ago, AyrJambo said:

 

I have no issue with you, your family, anyone from England or indeed anywhere else who chooses to come here to live/work/rest/ or otherwise lead their life
I have in the past chosen to live and work abroad and I would react the way you have if someone had called me a "settler" or "occupier" so apologies for any offence but I was not referring to any individual people

It's not about individuals it's about the inherent imbalance built in to a union between two countries where one has a population over 10 times the size of the other

 

Population of the UK and its constituent countries, mid-2021

 

UK        67,026,000    
England        56,536,000    
Wales        3,105,000    
Northern Ireland    1,905,000    
Scotland        5,480,000 

 

If 10% of the Scottish population moved to England they would make up around 0.9% of the population in England - very easily assimilated
If 10% of the English population moved to Scotland they would make up around a whopping 103% of the populattion in Scotland - not so easily assimilated

 

The 2011 census shows that the largest group of migrants living in Scotland was around 500,000 people born in England and Wales and based on recent trends will probably exceed 750,000 by now - that is well over 10% of the population

Additionally these migrants tend to be professionals - doctors, academics, civil servants and teachers - so policy-shapers and opinion formers
For example in 2018 33% of all teachers across Scotland were from England

 

I'm not arguing that only Scots should be allowed to live and work in Scotland or that only Scots should be able to teach in Scotland but the levels of migration into Scotland from one other country, England, are a form of de facto colonisation

It works both ways plenty Scot’s in England and are welcomed 

[AyrJambo]

5 minutes ago, JudyJudyJudy said:

It works both ways plenty Scot’s in England and are welcomed 

Did you read the numbers?

0.9% would have little effect on English culture and institutions

13% to 15% is a different ball game

Edited March 22 by AyrJambo

[Lord Montpelier]

27 minutes ago, AyrJambo said:

 

I have no issue with you, your family, anyone from England or indeed anywhere else who chooses to come here to live/work/rest/ or otherwise lead their life
I have in the past chosen to live and work abroad and I would react the way you have if someone had called me a "settler" or "occupier" so apologies for any offence but I was not referring to any individual people

It's not about individuals it's about the inherent imbalance built in to a union between two countries where one has a population over 10 times the size of the other

 

Population of the UK and its constituent countries, mid-2021

 

UK        67,026,000    
England        56,536,000    
Wales        3,105,000    
Northern Ireland    1,905,000    
Scotland        5,480,000 

 

If 10% of the Scottish population moved to England they would make up around 0.9% of the population in England - very easily assimilated
If 10% of the English population moved to Scotland they would make up around a whopping 103% of the populattion in Scotland - not so easily assimilated

 

The 2011 census shows that the largest group of migrants living in Scotland was around 500,000 people born in England and Wales and based on recent trends will probably exceed 750,000 by now - that is well over 10% of the population

Additionally these migrants tend to be professionals - doctors, academics, civil servants and teachers - so policy-shapers and opinion formers
For example in 2018 33% of all teachers across Scotland were from England

 

I'm not arguing that only Scots should be allowed to live and work in Scotland or that only Scots should be able to teach in Scotland but the levels of migration into Scotland from one other country, England, are a form of de facto colonisation

We should be applauding these "migrants" crossing the border into Scotland with their professional skills and experience imo. Well done them

[pablo]

48 minutes ago, AyrJambo said:

 

I have no issue with you, your family, anyone from England or indeed anywhere else who chooses to come here to live/work/rest/ or otherwise lead their life
I have in the past chosen to live and work abroad and I would react the way you have if someone had called me a "settler" or "occupier" so apologies for any offence but I was not referring to any individual people

It's not about individuals it's about the inherent imbalance built in to a union between two countries where one has a population over 10 times the size of the other

 

Population of the UK and its constituent countries, mid-2021

 

UK        67,026,000    
England        56,536,000    
Wales        3,105,000    
Northern Ireland    1,905,000    
Scotland        5,480,000 

 

If 10% of the Scottish population moved to England they would make up around 0.9% of the population in England - very easily assimilated
If 10% of the English population moved to Scotland they would make up around a whopping 103% of the populattion in Scotland - not so easily assimilated

 

The 2011 census shows that the largest group of migrants living in Scotland was around 500,000 people born in England and Wales and based on recent trends will probably exceed 750,000 by now - that is well over 10% of the population

Additionally these migrants tend to be professionals - doctors, academics, civil servants and teachers - so policy-shapers and opinion formers
For example in 2018 33% of all teachers across Scotland were from England

 

I'm not arguing that only Scots should be allowed to live and work in Scotland or that only Scots should be able to teach in Scotland but the levels of migration into Scotland from one other country, England, are a form of de facto colonisation

 

Holy shit. That's abhorrent. 

[JudyJudyJudy]

1 hour ago, AyrJambo said:

Did you read the numbers?

0.9% would have little effect on English culture and institutions

13% to 15% is a different ball game

So what? we are the United Kingdom . We can live and move anywhere in this union. What a very parachochial xeonphobic SNP attitude. 

[JudyJudyJudy]

55 minutes ago, Lord Montpelier said:

We should be applauding these "migrants" crossing the border into Scotland with their professional skills and experience imo. Well done them

I know  Bloody cheek they have with all them professional skills and experience and working too. Contribuiting . Probably paying more taxes than some others too.