Jump to content

Mafia - Birthday Bonanza


Shapes

Recommended Posts

Prince Buaben
10 minutes ago, Stuart McNeill said:

The turncoat didn't know who they were 

 

Sorry my bad. I thought they did

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 1.4k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • Tenaciousdandy

    182

  • Stuart McNeill

    170

  • Boof

    98

  • Shapes

    97

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted Images

yvonnejambo

So I don’t think the masons should out themselves, but if about to be lynched then say. If then someone like Stuart 😡 who counter claims your role it will show the next day who was genuine and who is goon. 
 

Goon lists would be good if masons all put different people on them as that will also help if lynched/ killed to figure out who can’t be a mason or known good. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Peakybunnet

Still something about Andy getting taken out by the assassin in my mind as well. 

 

I thought Stuart was assassin but then surprised nobody else was taken out. There are no extra bullets for the assassin so they are maybe keeping for late in the game. 

 

There are some very quiet players in the game now Riddley and Andy are gone. 

 

This is going to be a slog with 5 goons left.

 

What's the chances of Dunks and Wee Jambo both being goons? 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

40 minutes ago, Vlad Magic said:

Reading back and trying to work out what went on.

 

Ians to good a player to get so blatantly involved so early in the game. For the time being I’m putting his vote on Riddley as a first day cock up. 
 

Alim on the other hand is very keen to point the finger elsewhere. Whereas Ian’s vote appeared random Alim’s seemed deliberate?

 

Thats all I have to go on for the time being folks. 


Em you were the one messing around with stuff late on forcing me to change my vote to protect myself. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

22 minutes ago, Vlad Magic said:

Just checked back and my Unvote on Stuart and voting Alim put Alim into the tie.

 

Alim then voted Stuart right at the death.

 

Vote Alim


Again you were the one instigating all the late vote changing. I though your vote put me into the lead fwiw hence me voting Stuart to protect myself 

 

Vote Vlad 

 

clearly the trouble maker in all this. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Stuart McNeill
13 minutes ago, yvonnejambo said:

So I don’t think the masons should out themselves, but if about to be lynched then say. If then someone like Stuart 😡 who counter claims your role it will show the next day who was genuine and who is goon. 
 

Goon lists would be good if masons all put different people on them as that will also help if lynched/ killed to figure out who can’t be a mason or known good. 

Hi Yvonne 🖐️. I'm sure a trilogy will be planned at somepoint but it won't be this game. 😂

 

At least from me anyway. 

 

Regarding your second point. Isn't that only useful if we need to protect the masons? 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Prince Buaben
11 minutes ago, Stuart McNeill said:

Hi Yvonne 🖐️. I'm sure a trilogy will be planned at somepoint but it won't be this game. 😂

 

At least from me anyway. 

 

Regarding your second point. Isn't that only useful if we need to protect the masons? 

 

 

Surely we should still protect them to a point though as they are a team who can communicate with each other. They wont get an investigation unless they have the parcel but can still back each other up and influence people?

 

Not keen on offering them up for slaughter

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Stuart McNeill
Just now, Prince Buaben said:

 

Surely we should still protect them to a point though as they are a team who can communicate with each other. They wont get an investigation unless they have the parcel but can still back each other up and influence people?

 

Not keen on offering them up for slaughter

When I mentioned it. I didn't mean I want them known to the world. 

 

 

It was more just a question tbf 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Prince Buaben
20 minutes ago, Stuart McNeill said:

When I mentioned it. I didn't mean I want them known to the world. 

 

 

It was more just a question tbf 

 

 

 

Still to early to let the world know.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Good Old Fashioned Scandal

It would be so easy for the goons to win if we reveal the masons. There's only a max of 2 saves per night, and 3 masons.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The Hogfather
4 minutes ago, Good Old Fashioned Scandal said:

It would be so easy for the goons to win if we reveal the masons. There's only a max of 2 saves per night, and 3 masons.

 

This is why I think we need to be cautious going forward. The parcel means you're talking two saves, one investigation or two kills. The masons being obvious could lead to us losing two in one fell swoop.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Right before night, Riddley put Boof out in front, only for Alim to save him. Although he claimed that Stuart was on 4, he still saved Boof rather than himself.

 

Are we any clearer on who the active Riddley votes were yet, Since Boof and Dandy's information was wrong - intentionally or otherwise :whistling:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Peakybunnet
10 hours ago, Boof said:
dunks votes wee jambo
dandy votes dunks
rudi votes riddley
vlad votes rudi
riddley votes gofs
stuart votes ian
yvonne votes stuart
prince votes sheldon
andy votes peaky
ian votes stuart
andy unvotes peaky
andy votes riddley
andy unvotes riddley
seats votes boof
andy votes riddley
andy unvotes riddley
stuart unvotes ian
stuart votes riddley
alim votes stuart
alim unvotes stuart
ian unvotes stuart
ian votes riddley
andy votes riddley
sean votes riddley
peaky votes andy
alim votes riddley
sean unvotes riddley
alim unvotes riddley
ian unvotes riddley
wee jambo votes dunks
andy unvotes riddley
dunks unvotes wee jambo
dunks votes andy
andy votes dunks
ian votes stuart
sean votes dunks
bunny votes boof
sean unvotes dunks
sean votes seats
dunks unvotes andy
dunks votes ian
sean unvotes seats
sean votes dandy
assassin killed andy
sean unvotes dandy
sean votes wee jambo
peaky unvotes andy
peaky votes stuart
wee jambo unvotes dunks
riddley unvotes gofs
riddley votes seats
nunya votes yvonne
alim votes boof
boof votes alim
stuart unvotes ian
stuart votes alim
alim unvotes boof
alim votes stuart
gofs votes bunny
seats unvotes boof
seats votes alim
boof unvotes alim
wee jambo votes alim
stuart unvotes alim
stuart votes boof
alim unvotes stuart
alim votes boof
boof votes dandy
sheldon votes seats
vlad unvotes alim
vlad votes stuart
ian unvotes stuart
ian votes riddley
riddley unvotes seats
riddley votes stuart
dandy unvotes dunks
dandy votes ian
vlad unvotes rudi
vlad votes stuart
vlad unvotes stuart
vlad votes alim
riddley unvotes stuart
riddley votes boof
alim unvotes boof
alim votes stuart

 

 

Riddley voted by Ian, Sean, Rudi

Alim voted by Vlad, Wee Jambo, Seats

Stuart voted by Alim, Peaky, Yvonne

Boof voted by Riddley, Stuart, Bunny

 

Might be handy to fine-tune that to see who voted early, late, got involved in the switching shenanigans.

 

We know Riddley was a good guy. I know I'm a good guy...feel free to disbelieve me.

 

Why would Alim unvote me? Leave me on 4 and I'm a goner - a goon would be happy to NOT be in the tie. But Alim dragged Stuart into the tie. Bear in mind this was during the last few seconds - too late to react.

Let's see...

Riddley (known good) takes Stuart out the tie and puts me ahead as simultaneously Alim takes me out of the lead and puts Stuart ahead.

 

So Alim, wishing to save himself, thought he'd be putting Stuart further ahead - this at a time Stuart was away to the telly and seemingly unconcerned about saving himself.

 

That's all I've got to go on but at least I'm trying.

 

Fingers crossed the assassin hasn't whacked me while I've been typing! :lol: 

 

Unvote Dandy

 

Vote Alim Ozturk

 

I am the opposite. Dandy has hardly been his usual self. No to many posts or votes. Then he pops up at the end to stick a vote on Ian and unvoted Dunks who wasn't in real danger?

 

He hasnt produced a voting list either and left it to Boof (pre arranged?)

 

Vote Dandy

 

Something not quite right. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Peakybunnet
1 minute ago, Dunks said:

Right before night, Riddley put Boof out in front, only for Alim to save him. Although he claimed that Stuart was on 4, he still saved Boof rather than himself.

 

Are we any clearer on who the active Riddley votes were yet, Since Boof and Dandy's information was wrong - intentionally or otherwise :whistling:

 

See my post above for votes

Link to comment
Share on other sites

So the active votes on Riddley were Rudi, Stuart and Ian.

 

Boof hiding Stuart or framing Sean?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Dr. Sheldon Cooper
10 hours ago, Boof said:
dunks votes wee jambo
dandy votes dunks
rudi votes riddley
vlad votes rudi
riddley votes gofs
stuart votes ian
yvonne votes stuart
prince votes sheldon
andy votes peaky
ian votes stuart
andy unvotes peaky
andy votes riddley
andy unvotes riddley
seats votes boof
andy votes riddley
andy unvotes riddley
stuart unvotes ian
stuart votes riddley
alim votes stuart
alim unvotes stuart
ian unvotes stuart
ian votes riddley
andy votes riddley
sean votes riddley
peaky votes andy
alim votes riddley
sean unvotes riddley
alim unvotes riddley
ian unvotes riddley
wee jambo votes dunks
andy unvotes riddley
dunks unvotes wee jambo
dunks votes andy
andy votes dunks
ian votes stuart
sean votes dunks
bunny votes boof
sean unvotes dunks
sean votes seats
dunks unvotes andy
dunks votes ian
sean unvotes seats
sean votes dandy
assassin killed andy
sean unvotes dandy
sean votes wee jambo
peaky unvotes andy
peaky votes stuart
wee jambo unvotes dunks
riddley unvotes gofs
riddley votes seats
nunya votes yvonne
alim votes boof
boof votes alim
stuart unvotes ian
stuart votes alim
alim unvotes boof
alim votes stuart
gofs votes bunny
seats unvotes boof
seats votes alim
boof unvotes alim
wee jambo votes alim
stuart unvotes alim
stuart votes boof
alim unvotes stuart
alim votes boof
boof votes dandy
sheldon votes seats
vlad unvotes alim
vlad votes stuart
ian unvotes stuart
ian votes riddley
riddley unvotes seats
riddley votes stuart
dandy unvotes dunks
dandy votes ian
vlad unvotes rudi
vlad votes stuart
vlad unvotes stuart
vlad votes alim
riddley unvotes stuart
riddley votes boof
alim unvotes boof
alim votes stuart

 

 

10 hours ago, Dr. Sheldon Cooper said:

One thing that stands out for me from Boof's spreadsheet there is that Ian and Alim seemed to take turns going between Stuart and Riddley.  At points they followed each other in voting and unvoting for the same person before one settled on Riddley and one settled on Stuart (discounting the random vote on Boof from Alim before switching back to Stuart right at the end).

 

Could be nothing, could be something or could be pure coincidence but thought it was worth noting.

 

In addition to this, there also seems to be consistent patterns with Stuart along with Alim and Ian.

 

Alim did his usual of voting for Stuart, then unvoted straight away before mirroring Stuart's vote on Riddley.  Alim then went through a phase of switching between Boof and Stuart, before settling on Boof right after Stuart also voted for him.  Stuart disappeared to go and watch TV, then Alim went and placed a vote on Stuart at the end to bring him into the tie, but seemed to think he was putting Stuart in the lead?

 

Something isn't quite right here.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 minutes ago, Dr. Sheldon Cooper said:

 

 

In addition to this, there also seems to be consistent patterns with Stuart along with Alim and Ian.

 

Alim did his usual of voting for Stuart, then unvoted straight away before mirroring Stuart's vote on Riddley.  Alim then went through a phase of switching between Boof and Stuart, before settling on Boof right after Stuart also voted for him.  Stuart disappeared to go and watch TV, then Alim went and placed a vote on Stuart at the end to bring him into the tie, but seemed to think he was putting Stuart in the lead?

 

Something isn't quite right here.


Aii because it was pretty fecking clear that riddley was the cop. 
 

Vlad was the one who caused all the mayhem at the end there. I was protecting myself and thought I was protecting riddley.

 

 

Edited by AlimOzturk
Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 minutes ago, AlimOzturk said:


Aii because it was pretty fecking clear that riddley was the cop. 
 

Vlad was the one who caused all the mayhem at the end there. I was protecting myself and thought I was protecting riddley.

 

 

 

By saving Boof? 🤷‍♂️

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 minutes ago, Dunks said:

 

By saving Boof? 🤷‍♂️


I tried to put Stuart in the lead. I can’t help others late voting ruining that. Vlad is the one you should be looking at not me. I wasn’t for dying early on either. 

Edited by AlimOzturk
Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 minutes ago, Wee jambo said:

went to bed early last night just Caught up with the thread dunks acting a bit sus but I’ll stay on alim


What ever wee goon. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

19 minutes ago, AlimOzturk said:


What ever wee goon. 

I’m not a goon but your new name should be alim goon boy

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Stuart McNeill
1 minute ago, Dunks said:

 

You had the second :thumbsup:

So that's where the confusion is and Boof shouldn't have been in the tie. As my Unvote on riddley was actually an Unvote on Ian and I then voted boof. 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

yvonnejambo

Who would be a prime candidate for the goons to go for in hope turncoat? Or were they hoping to get Doc/ assassin/ mason?

 

if going for turncoat I would say the folk high up picking would be between 

Dunks

Sheldon

Dandy

Prince

Sean

 

Any of them could be goons already but I’m just thinking of who would you try to turn if a goon.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Dr. Sheldon Cooper

Not sure how I feel about rushing into the Alim lynch.  Something isn't right with the voting as I've highlighted but I think I'm leaning towards another player.

 

Vote Stuart

Link to comment
Share on other sites

27 minutes ago, Stuart McNeill said:

So that's where the confusion is and Boof shouldn't have been in the tie. As my Unvote on riddley was actually an Unvote on Ian and I then voted boof. 

 

 

 

Yeah, I'm just going by Boof's list which may actually be Dandys. It's Shapes that counts and we are where we are.

 

Further highlights suspicion of Boof and Dandy though.

 

Unvote Ian

 

Vote Boof

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Tenaciousdandy
1 hour ago, Peakybunnet said:

 

I am the opposite. Dandy has hardly been his usual self. No to many posts or votes. Then he pops up at the end to stick a vote on Ian and unvoted Dunks who wasn't in real danger?

 

He hasnt produced a voting list either and left it to Boof (pre arranged?)

 

Vote Dandy

 

Something not quite right. 

Hmm not sure if your trying to set me and boof up or not, If you look back you see that it was me that produced the voting and boof just use my voting pattern list, tje reason I changed to Ian is I thought he seemed dodgy, I agreed with riddley that anyone wanting rid of him wasn't for the town 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Tenaciousdandy
1 hour ago, Dunks said:

Right before night, Riddley put Boof out in front, only for Alim to save him. Although he claimed that Stuart was on 4, he still saved Boof rather than himself.

 

Are we any clearer on who the active Riddley votes were yet, Since Boof and Dandy's information was wrong - intentionally or otherwise :whistling:

Where is my info wrong? I pointed earlier that Stuart made a mistake with unvoting Ian instead of riddley

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Tenaciousdandy
36 minutes ago, yvonnejambo said:

Who would be a prime candidate for the goons to go for in hope turncoat? Or were they hoping to get Doc/ assassin/ mason?

 

if going for turncoat I would say the folk high up picking would be between 

Dunks

Sheldon

Dandy

Prince

Sean

 

Any of them could be goons already but I’m just thinking of who would you try to turn if a goon.

 

I think you'd be quite high up on day 1 kills also tbh 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Stuart McNeill
10 minutes ago, Tenaciousdandy said:

I think you'd be quite high up on day 1 kills also tbh 

I don't think going down that route will help. 

 

 

Realistically the way I see it. Anyone can be the turncoat. 

 

Edit : im agreeing with you. Just to clarify. 

Edited by Stuart McNeill
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Tenaciousdandy
Just now, Wee jambo said:

No apart from alim maybe dunks

Didn't dunks hint at being the invincible townie? 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.




×
×
  • Create New...