Mafia battle of the bands

[Simo]

27 minutes ago, milky_26 said:

is that you apologising for killing the doc?

 

I don't recall apologising...

 

Nah in all seriousness if I was the assassin I'd be delighted at being 2 for 2 but I'm not so I'm not 🤷‍♂️

[milky_26]

1 minute ago, Boof said:

Seats had voted Nunya onto 1 a fair bit earlier

I voted Nunya onto 2 to see if it would provoke a reaction

Alim immediately unvoted Stuart onto 0 and voted Andy onto 2 into a tie with Nunya

Seats then unvoted Nunya onto 1 and voted Boof onto 1

Rudi then unvoted Vlad and voted Boof onto 2

 

Sorry - dunno why it's all bold. Red highlight is known bad, blue is known good.

 

Seats early vote for Nunya: goon-on-goon? Maybe...

Alim vote Andy into a Nunya-tie: protect fellow goon? Maybe...

Seats unvote Nunya: protect fellow goon? Maybe...

 

Rudi, I'd say, for the moment is off the GnR dodgy list due to taking Seats onto 4 later.

 

Vote Nunya Business

would they be that obvious? possibly. i'll wait to see if others jump on this

[Vlad Magic]

Here we go.

 

A couple of votes that people don’t like and the goons come scurrying out the woodwork to defend their goon friends.

 

[Simo]

5 minutes ago, Boof said:

Seats had voted Nunya onto 1 a fair bit earlier

I voted Nunya onto 2 to see if it would provoke a reaction

Alim immediately unvoted Stuart onto 0 and voted Andy onto 2 into a tie with Nunya

Seats then unvoted Nunya onto 1 and voted Boof onto 1

Rudi then unvoted Vlad and voted Boof onto 2

 

Sorry - dunno why it's all bold. Red highlight is known bad, blue is known good.

 

Seats early vote for Nunya: goon-on-goon? Maybe...

Alim vote Andy into a Nunya-tie: protect fellow goon? Maybe...

Seats unvote Nunya: protect fellow goon? Maybe...

 

Rudi, I'd say, for the moment is off the GnR dodgy list due to taking Seats onto 4 later.

 

Vote Nunya Business

 

Interesting... Certainly the most suspicious voting I've seen so far 🤔

[milky_26]

1 minute ago, Vlad Magic said:

Here we go.

 

A couple of votes that people don’t like and the goons come scurrying out the woodwork to defend their goon friends.

 

poor attempt at deflection vlad magoon

[Tenaciousdandy]

3 minutes ago, Boof said:

Seats had voted Nunya onto 1 a fair bit earlier

I voted Nunya onto 2 to see if it would provoke a reaction

Alim immediately unvoted Stuart onto 0 and voted Andy onto 2 into a tie with Nunya

Seats then unvoted Nunya onto 1 and voted Boof onto 1

Rudi then unvoted Vlad and voted Boof onto 2

 

Sorry - dunno why it's all bold. Red highlight is known bad, blue is known good.

 

Seats early vote for Nunya: goon-on-goon? Maybe...

Alim vote Andy into a Nunya-tie: protect fellow goon? Maybe...

Seats unvote Nunya: protect fellow goon? Maybe...

 

Rudi, I'd say, for the moment is off the GnR dodgy list due to taking Seats onto 4 later.

 

Vote Nunya Business

It's a possibility, it's a common tactic for goons to put a vote on fellow goons early on day 1

[milky_26]

if nunya is not a goon and spcifically one of the gnr team then that will make boof look suspect

[Vlad Magic]

2 minutes ago, milky_26 said:

if nunya is not a goon and spcifically one of the gnr team then that will make boof look suspect

GNR is a goon team!!

 

You’re now pointing the finger at Boof?

 

Ill leave this for now but you are all over the place today?

[Tenaciousdandy]

Just now, Vlad Magic said:

GNR is a goon team!!

 

You’re now pointing the finger at Boof?

 

Ill leave this for now but you are all over the place today?

He's trying to say that if nunya isn't part of gnrs, then it could be that boof is and trying to deflect away 

[Shapes]

3 minutes ago, Vlad Magic said:

GNR is a goon team!!

 

You’re now pointing the finger at Boof?

 

Ill leave this for now but you are all over the place today?

Anything to say about you and Riddleys exchange?

[milky_26]

2 minutes ago, Tenaciousdandy said:

He's trying to say that if nunya isn't part of gnrs, then it could be that boof is and trying to deflect away 

im glad someone got my poorly put over point

[Vlad Magic]

2 minutes ago, Shapes said:

Anything to say about you and Riddleys exchange?

What can I say? It was typical first day not got a clue what anyone is stuff?

[Vlad Magic]

5 minutes ago, Tenaciousdandy said:

He's trying to say that if nunya isn't part of gnrs, then it could be that boof is and trying to deflect away 

That’s one way of interpreting it.

[milky_26]

1 minute ago, Vlad Magic said:

What can I say? It was typical first day not got a clue what anyone is stuff?

yet you bring up an exchange between me and riddley (who ended up being a good roled player)

[Boof]

13 minutes ago, milky_26 said:

would they be that obvious?

 

Dunno - it's all I can find at the moment though.

 

13 minutes ago, milky_26 said:

possibly. i'll wait to see if others jump on this

 

I don't want anyone to jump on it! Unless Nunya's a goon, of course. I'm merely justifying my vote with the only information I have available.

 

[Boof]

8 minutes ago, Tenaciousdandy said:

He's trying to say that if nunya isn't part of gnrs, then it could be that boof is and trying to deflect away 

 

Possibly plausible...if I hadn't actually voted for Seats who ended up lynched by only one vote.

[Tenaciousdandy]

2 minutes ago, Boof said:

 

Possibly plausible...if I hadn't actually voted for Seats who ended up lynched by only one vote.

I'm not saying that's what you are doing, just explaining what milky was implying 

[Vlad Magic]

7 minutes ago, milky_26 said:

yet you bring up an exchange between me and riddley (who ended up being a good roled player)

Correct. Who is now dead.

[milky_26]

2 minutes ago, Vlad Magic said:

Correct. Who is now dead.

youre implication was that the exchange between me and riddley was between two goons. which is quite clearly wrong

[Shapes]

7 minutes ago, Vlad Magic said:

Correct. Who is now dead.

Riddley who is dead after calling you a goon

[Vlad Magic]

23 minutes ago, Shapes said:

Riddley who is dead after calling you a goon

 

23 minutes ago, Shapes said:

Riddley who is dead after calling you a goon

Who didn’t know I was a goon.

 

Its bleedingly obvious what’s going on here.

 

As a townie it’s my job to prod people and get reactions.

 

Job done 👍👍

[Shapes]

2 minutes ago, Vlad Magic said:

 

Who didn’t know I was a goon.

 

Its bleedingly obvious what’s going on here.

 

As a townie it’s my job to prod people and get reactions.

 

Job done 👍👍

So how is it ok for you to 'get a reaction' from milky but I do the same with you and it's all games and you're the one who has managed to get reactions? Looks to me like I've managed to get a reaction out of you by bringing up the fact riddley called you a goon and is now dead 

[Vlad Magic]

2 minutes ago, Shapes said:

So how is it ok for you to 'get a reaction' from milky but I do the same with you and it's all games and you're the one who has managed to get reactions? Looks to me like I've managed to get a reaction out of you by bringing up the fact riddley called you a goon and is now dead 

What reaction? You’re making things up.

 

All you are doing now is making yourself look more goonly. A wee double team with Milky.

 

Notice no one is backing me? That’s because I’m town. I’m fine with it as I can happily be sacrificed and take 2 goons down on the back of it 👍👍

[Vlad Magic]

2 investigations last night both found good players.

 

I would bet a good few quid I was so be of them.

[Shapes]

3 minutes ago, Vlad Magic said:

What reaction? You’re making things up.

 

All you are doing now is making yourself look more goonly. A wee double team with Milky.

 

Notice no one is backing me? That’s because I’m town. I’m fine with it as I can happily be sacrificed and take 2 goons down on the back of it 👍👍

Vlad, you've had a nightmare. 

 

'As a townie it's my job to prod people and get a reaction' 

 

That's exactly what I'm doing too and I've managed to get one from you by bringing up your riddley interaction and your reaction is to accuse me and milky of being in a goon team together. If you think me bringing up an interaction from yesterday is goonly then I can throw that back at you for bringing up milky and Riddleys interaction. Seems it's okay for you to 'prod' but I'm doing the same and I'm being accused of being a goon 

[Shapes]

6 minutes ago, Vlad Magic said:

2 investigations last night both found good players.

 

I would bet a good few quid I was so be of them.

One investigation and one being watched so that would only come back if you were cop/mason. So if you are a townie like you say you are that's one shot at being investigated last night. What do you think you did that makes you a candidate for investigation?

[Peakybunnet]

Good wee spat between Shapes, Milky and Vlad. With only 4 real townies I have my doubts they all are.

 

Meantime how many lurkers have we. Who isn't playing their usual game? 

 

Time for a look back. 

[Vlad Magic]

9 minutes ago, Shapes said:

One investigation and one being watched so that would only come back if you were cop/mason. So if you are a townie like you say you are that's one shot at being investigated last night. What do you think you did that makes you a candidate for investigation?

I didn’t say I did anything.

 

I said I would bet a good few quid I was one of them.

 

Milky now gone quiet and Shapes taken over the interrogation!!

 

 

[Simo]

Purely gut feeling but not convinced there's much incriminating in the Vlad/Riddley exchange tbh 

[Simo]

There was only one investigation though right? 

[Vlad Magic]

16 hours ago, yvonnejambo said:

During the after party The Police found someone good. 
Robert Smith watched over someone who was safe.
Lady Gaga decided to keep hold of powers, but The Killers decided she had to go. Riddley RJ Walker 😟 never got the chance to help the town as stabbed in the heart by them. 

The Chemical Bros found someone doing good. 
 

Now day and deadline 9pm tomorrow.

Jack D will be modkilled if doesn’t post and vote tomorrow  

2 investigations 👍👍

[Vlad Magic]

Unvote Milky

[Peakybunnet]

Nothing sticks out, but looking back at the Andy killing by the assassin, 2 votes were put in amongst he faux cry's of rage. 

 

Simo voted smack

 

And Ian voted Vlad.

 

Cant see anything to support their votes.

 

So as you voted me yesterday and cant see why you voted Smack

 

Vote Simo

 

 

[Boof]

1 hour ago, Tenaciousdandy said:

I'm not saying that's what you are doing, just explaining what milky was implying 

 

And I guess I was just quoting you as you'd pointed it out but I simply wished to point out the sheer improbability of me being in Seats' team.

[yvonnejambo]

Votes so far

Shapes -1

Jack D -1

Prince -1 

Peaky -1

Nunya -1

Simo -1

Smack -1

Dandy -1

Vlad -1

 

 

Deadline 9pm tonight 

[Rudi Skacel]

Ooft. Had a day golfing and come back to losing the doc. 
 

good job from the assassin from their perspective I guess. 2 shots and 2 roles. 
 

also scotland losing aswell. Class!

[Shapes]

40 minutes ago, Vlad Magic said:

2 investigations 👍👍

One investigation and one 'watch' which doesnt reveal roles, only if the person was performing night activity

[Tenaciousdandy]

Just now, Shapes said:

One investigation and one 'watch' which doesnt reveal roles, only if the person was performing night activity

Said watched someone doing good, could have been riddley that was watched which would be unfortunate if it was as it wouldn't help with regards to a trust list 

[Peakybunnet]

6 minutes ago, Tenaciousdandy said:

Said watched someone doing good, could have been riddley that was watched which would be unfortunate if it was as it wouldn't help with regards to a trust list 

 

Thought Supertownie didn't do anything last night? Had to be Doc? 

[milky_26]

17 hours ago, yvonnejambo said:

During the after party The Police found someone good. 
Robert Smith watched over someone who was safe.
Lady Gaga decided to keep hold of powers, but The Killers decided she had to go. Riddley RJ Walker 😟 never got the chance to help the town as stabbed in the heart by them. 

The Chemical Bros found someone doing good. 
 

Now day and deadline 9pm tomorrow.

Jack D will be modkilled if doesn’t post and vote tomorrow  

 

6 minutes ago, Tenaciousdandy said:

Said watched someone doing good, could have been riddley that was watched which would be unfortunate if it was as it wouldn't help with regards to a trust list 

i think the watchers would only see someone if they were doing something, riddley did not use an action so i dont think would show up as good to the watchers

[milky_26]

1 minute ago, Peakybunnet said:

 

Thought Supertownie didn't do anything last night? Had to be Doc? 

or cop

[Tenaciousdandy]

2 minutes ago, Peakybunnet said:

 

Thought Supertownie didn't do anything last night? Had to be Doc? 

 

1 minute ago, milky_26 said:

 

i think the watchers would only see someone if they were doing something, riddley did not use an action so i dont think would show up as good to the watchers

 

1 minute ago, milky_26 said:

or cop

Sorry got Andy and riddley mixed up, Riddley was the doc in my game lol

[Dr. Sheldon Cooper]

2 hours ago, milky_26 said:

so what did you make of the vote switching?

 

trying to hide in plain sight?

 

I don't know, that's why I need to go back and have a look.

 

I've been out all afternoon and now back on the beers so apologies for lack of contribution so far today.

 

One thing I would say is that it's hard to read into the Riddley thing too much. Nobody would've known his role at the time.

[Simo]

So the chemical brothers either watched Andy or know who the cop is? Latter would be decent as they could hopefully help divert people away if cop looked in danger of being lynched. 

 

I think I said at the time Peaky but my vote for Smack was just a punt. I figured the people who voted for seats are unlikely to be in Guns n Roses so just took a punt between the remaining players 😂🤷‍♂️

[Boof]

On 13/03/2021 at 14:08, yvonnejambo said:

Bad guys

 

local singers x 4

Normal townies who just want to sing and get rid of the bad bands

 

 

 

Just having a look back to Yvonne's OP as I'm still trying to get to grips with what everyone does and was just a little tickled to see vanilla townies lumped in with the bad guys  

 

I mean...my singing isn't that bad, surely?  

 

So...the Chemical Brothers must've watched either Doc or Cop (hopefully Cop to get a little bit of a trust list going). Is that right?

 

And the Black Keys...can they win as part of the town if they get through the game unlynched and unturned?

[Shapes]

Would the chemical brothers watch the masons too as they're all part of 'the police'? 

[Tenaciousdandy]

3 minutes ago, Simo said:

So the chemical brothers either watched Andy or know who the cop is? Latter would be decent as they could hopefully help divert people away if cop looked in danger of being lynched. 

 

I think I said at the time Peaky but my vote for Smack was just a punt. I figured the people who voted for seats are unlikely to be in Guns n Roses so just took a punt between the remaining players 😂🤷‍♂️

It's looks likely we can rule , Dunks, gofs boof and rudi out of being in gnrs

Boofs theory regarding the votes around nunya could be something worth looking at, Seats had a safe vote on nunya, only to unvote when boof put him into a tie with riddley

 

Vlad putting riddley out in front when seats was in the tie

 

Might be nothing in these things but there isn't a lot else to go on as usual 

 

[yvonnejambo]

14 minutes ago, Boof said:

 

Just having a look back to Yvonne's OP as I'm still trying to get to grips with what everyone does and was just a little tickled to see vanilla townies lumped in with the bad guys  

 

I mean...my singing isn't that bad, surely?  

 

So...the Chemical Brothers must've watched either Doc or Cop (hopefully Cop to get a little bit of a trust list going). Is that right?

 

And the Black Keys...can they win as part of the town if they get through the game unlynched and unturned?

The Chemical Bros will see anyone who is in the goon team that is active that night or any of the Police team.

 

The Black Keys are not roled and if don’t get turned by either bad band they stay good.

[Shapes]

I'm gonna go with my gut and 

 

vote vlad 

[Dunks]

I was a wee bit suspicious of Rudi in the late votes until Riddley's role was revealed. My assumption therefore is that Rudi just didn't want Riddley lynched on day 1 again.

 

Cop may have investigated Rudi or Riddley for the same reason I guess, but either way, I'm inclined to trust Rudi.