What is Robbie's record in Derbies as a manager?

[Bigteam]

Managers in 4 Derbies or more

 

Ranked by Loss %

 

Tommy Walker worse than Robbie!

 

1    Paulo Sergio from 2011-12 to 2011-12 P4 W4 D0 L0 W100.00% D0.00% L0.00% F12 A2

2    Sandy Clark from 1993-94 to 1993-94 P5 W3 D2 L0 W60.00% D40.00% L0.00% F6 A2

3    Peter Fairley from 1901-02 to 1902-03 P4 W2 D2 L0 W50.00% D50.00% L0.00% F5 A3

3    David Pratt from 1935-36 to 1936-37 P4 W2 D2 L0 W50.00% D50.00% L0.00% F15 A9

5    Joe Jordan from 1990-91 to 1992-93 P11 W5 D6 L0 W45.45% D54.55% L0.00% F14 A6

6    Alex MacDonald from 1983-84 to 1989-90 P28 W13 D12 L3 W46.43% D42.86% L10.71% F37 A24

7    Lindsay Waugh from 1903-04 to 1907-08 P9 W7 D1 L1 W77.78% D11.11% L11.11% F18 A8

8    John McCartney from 1909-10 to 1919-20 P23 W17 D3 L3 W73.91% D13.04% L13.04% F48 A19

9    Craig Levein from 2000-01 to 2004-05 P12 W5 D5 L2 W41.67% D41.67% L16.67% F21 A14

10    Jim Jefferies from 1995-96 to 2010-11 P23 W11 D7 L5 W47.83% D30.43% L21.74% F35 A29

11    Anatoly Korobochka from 2006-07 to 2007-08 P4 W2 D1 L1 W50.00% D25.00% L25.00% F4 A2

11    Valdas Ivanauskas from 2005-06 to 2006-07 P4 W2 D1 L1 W50.00% D25.00% L25.00% F10 A6

13    Robbie Neilson from 2014-15 to 2014-15 P4 W1 D2 L1 W25.00% D50.00% L25.00% F4 A5

14    Gary Locke from 2012-13 to 2013-14 P7 W4 D1 L2 W57.14% D14.29% L28.57% F8 A5

15    Csaba Laszlo from 2008-09 to 2009-10 P7 W1 D4 L2 W14.29% D57.14% L28.57% F4 A4

16    Tommy Walker from 1951-52 to 1966-67 P40 W22 D6 L12 W55.00% D15.00% L30.00% F99 A66

17    Frank Moss from 1937-38 to 1939-40 P6 W3 D1 L2 W50.00% D16.67% L33.33% F15 A14

18    William McCartney from 1919-20 to 1934-35 P30 W7 D13 L10 W23.33% D43.33% L33.33% F46 A43

19    John Harvey from 1966-67 to 1970-71 P8 W1 D4 L3 W12.50% D50.00% L37.50% F4 A8

20    Committee from 1877-78 to 1900-01 P26 W10 D6 L10 W38.46% D23.08% L38.46% F44 A44

21    William Esplin Ormond from 1978-79 to 1978-79 P5 W1 D2 L2 W20.00% D40.00% L40.00% F6 A7

22    David McLean from 1941-42 to 1950-51 P23 W11 D2 L10 W47.83% D8.70% L43.48% F37 A40

23    John Hagart from 1974-75 to 1976-77 P9 W0 D4 L5 W0.00% D44.44% L55.56% F5 A13

24    Caretaker from 1907-08 to 2005-06 P8 W3 D0 L5 W37.50% D0.00% L62.50% F16 A16

25    Bobby Seith from 1970-71 to 1974-75 P9 W1 D2 L6 W11.11% D22.22% L66.67% F7 A19

26    Tommy McLean from 1994-95 to 1994-95 P4 W1 D0 L3 W25.00% D0.00% L75.00% F4 A6

thanks

[the big show]

i am being 100% genuine so no need for the smart arse comments and i agree with PTBCAL  i am unsure about his big game management. One of the draws was down to  Oz's late wonder strike but  to answer my question he has won once out of four games so his record is not the best

If i was hibs i would be more worried about stubbs record when it comes to big games or are we just to ignore all the facts that sit on the table or are we to accept stubbo's excuse's . i would also bet Robbie has the better record and that's without skooshing the league last year in a canter .

[Hannibal]

Robbie did get things wrong last season. He also got enough right to see us storm the league.

 

 

He learned though and much like many of our current team he is still learning.

 

 

Mistakes will still be made but he looks settled in his system now and for me the inconsistencies in our play have been more player related than management related. Rossi against Hamilton being a recent example.

 

We are still building and a long way from our finished product.

 

 

We aren't struggling to beat Morton by a single goal.

 

 

indeed he maybe got his tactics slightly wrong last season.

But after winning the first one and getting such a tremendous lead in the Championship race the onus was more on Rangers and Hibs to win the games involving us to try and reel us in and catch us.

By Beating Hibs and Rangers early on in the season and then Rangers at Tynecastle meant the two derby draws were better results for us than them.

And by the time we lost to Rangers and Hibs it really didnt matter that much.

 

Hibs can point to the fact they split the points with us last season if that makes them feel better.

 

I am confident we are going to start well and blow them away.

[Hearts Heritage]

10 or more games in charge

 

by win %

1    John McCartney from 1909-10 to 1919-20 P23 W17 D3 L3 W73.91% D13.04% L13.04% F48 A19
2    Tommy Walker from 1951-52 to 1966-67 P40 W22 D6 L12 W55.00% D15.00% L30.00% F99 A66
3    Jim Jefferies from 1995-96 to 2010-11 P23 W11 D7 L5 W47.83% D30.43% L21.74% F35 A29
4    David McLean from 1941-42 to 1950-51 P23 W11 D2 L10 W47.83% D8.70% L43.48% F37 A40
5    Alex MacDonald from 1983-84 to 1989-90 P28 W13 D12 L3 W46.43% D42.86% L10.71% F37 A24
6    Joe Jordan from 1990-91 to 1992-93 P11 W5 D6 L0 W45.45% D54.55% L0.00% F14 A6
7    Craig Levein from 2000-01 to 2004-05 P12 W5 D5 L2 W41.67% D41.67% L16.67% F21 A14
8    Committee from 1877-78 to 1900-01 P26 W10 D6 L10 W38.46% D23.08% L38.46% F44 A44
9    William McCartney from 1919-20 to 1934-35 P30 W7 D13 L10 W23.33% D43.33% L33.33% F46 A43

by losing %
1    Joe Jordan from 1990-91 to 1992-93 P11 W5 D6 L0 W45.45% D54.55% L0.00% F14 A6
2    Alex MacDonald from 1983-84 to 1989-90 P28 W13 D12 L3 W46.43% D42.86% L10.71% F37 A24
3    John McCartney from 1909-10 to 1919-20 P23 W17 D3 L3 W73.91% D13.04% L13.04% F48 A19
4    Craig Levein from 2000-01 to 2004-05 P12 W5 D5 L2 W41.67% D41.67% L16.67% F21 A14
5    Jim Jefferies from 1995-96 to 2010-11 P23 W11 D7 L5 W47.83% D30.43% L21.74% F35 A29
6    Tommy Walker from 1951-52 to 1966-67 P40 W22 D6 L12 W55.00% D15.00% L30.00% F99 A66
7    William McCartney from 1919-20 to 1934-35 P30 W7 D13 L10 W23.33% D43.33% L33.33% F46 A43
8    Committee from 1877-78 to 1900-01 P26 W10 D6 L10 W38.46% D23.08% L38.46% F44 A44
9    David McLean from 1941-42 to 1950-51 P23 W11 D2 L10 W47.83% D8.70% L43.48% F37 A40

[soonbe110]

yeah i get that but i still dont think his record or the way we play in big games is good but saying that the way we played against Aberdeen in the cup was spot on - hopefully he has learnt from that

And against Celtic in December. Learning all the time about himself and his squad. To be honest it wouldn't bother me if we never beat Hibs again with Robbie as manager as long as he wins league titles or has us in the mix for them every season.

[Bigteam]

at last some brilliant stats, thanks for that - if you can see above the arseholes on here you can get some sensible discussion!!

[Hearts Heritage]

The best Hibs Managers by their win %

 

1    Eddie Turnbull from 1971-72 to 1978-79 P21 L2 D7 W12 L9.52% D33.33% W57.14% A17 F37
2    Alex McLeish from 1997-98 to 2001-02 P10 L1 D4 W5 L10.00% D40.00% W50.00% A9 F19
3    Alex Maley from 1920-21 to 1924-25 P10 L2 D3 W5 L20.00% D30.00% W50.00% A14 F16
4    Jock Stein from 1964-65 to 1964-65 P4 L1 D1 W2 L25.00% D25.00% W50.00% A7 F9
5    William McCartney from 1936-37 to 1947-48 P29 L11 D4 W14 L37.93% D13.79% W48.28% A55 F62
6    Bob Shankly from 1965-66 to 1968-69 P9 L3 D2 W4 L33.33% D22.22% W44.44% A10 F16
7    Mika-Matti Petteri Paatelainen from 2007-08 to 2008-09 P6 L2 D2 W2 L33.33% D33.33% W33.33% A4 F3
8    Not Applicable from 1877-78 to 1902-03 P30 L12 D8 W10 L40.00% D26.67% W33.33% A49 F47
9    Tony Mowbray from 2004-05 to 2005-06 P9 L4 D2 W3 L44.44% D22.22% W33.33% A19 F11
10    John Collins from 2006-07 to 2007-08 P6 L3 D1 W2 L50.00% D16.67% W33.33% A7 F5
11    Hugh Shaw from 1948-49 to 1961-62 P31 L20 D3 W8 L64.52% D9.68% W25.81% A81 F46
12    Alan Stubbs from 2014-15 to 2014-15 P4 L1 D2 W1 L25.00% D50.00% W25.00% A4 F5
13    Pat Fenlon from 2011-12 to 2013-14 P10 L5 D3 W2 L50.00% D30.00% W20.00% A14 F6
14    Bobby Templeton from 1925-26 to 1935-36 P21 L6 D11 W4 L28.57% D52.38% W19.05% A40 F28
15    Alex Miller from 1986-87 to 1996-97 P40 L18 D15 W7 L45.00% D37.50% W17.50% A51 F32
16    Bobby Williamson from 2001-02 to 2003-04 P7 L4 D2 W1 L57.14% D28.57% W14.29% A16 F9
16    Walter Galbraith from 1961-62 to 1963-64 P7 L4 D2 W1 L57.14% D28.57% W14.29% A19 F10
18    Dan McMichael from 1903-04 to 1918-19 P36 L26 D5 W5 L72.22% D13.89% W13.89% A70 F29
19    Pat Stanton from 1983-84 to 1984-85 P5 L2 D3 W0 L40.00% D60.00% W0.00% A7 F5
20    John [8] Hughes from 2009-10 to 2009-10 P4 L2 D2 W0 L50.00% D50.00% W0.00% A5 F3
21    John Blackley from 1984-85 to 1986-87 P9 L5 D4 W0 L55.56% D44.44% W0.00% A15 F8
22    Colin Calderwood from 2010-11 to 2011-12 P4 L3 D1 W0 L75.00% D25.00% W0.00% A7 F2
23    James Duffy from 1996-97 to 1997-98 P5 L4 D1 W0 L80.00% D20.00% W0.00% A10 F2

[tynie chris]

i wished i had just asked London Hearts direct instead of posting on here. lesson learnt wont bother posting on here again

[colinmaroon]

some managers just have it when it comes to derbies but i dont think Robbie is one of them....what are his stats? 

 

 

Ooooffft!

 

The pong is dreadful!

[hmfc_liam06]

i wished i had just asked London Hearts direct instead of posting on here. lesson learnt wont bother posting on here again

 

Bye then.

[Oneneilberry]

His championship stats are competed in 1 won 1.

Stubbs is competed in 1lost 1.Not sure if this helps

[Generic Username]

Probably for the best if your laddie emancipates himself from you.

[Rudolf]

some managers just have it when it comes to derbies but i dont think Robbie is one of them....what are his stats?

Unbeaten in competitive games. Hearts treated the game Hibs closed to within 21 points of us as a friendly.

[Bigteam]

If i was hibs i would be more worried about stubbs record when it comes to big games or are we just to ignore all the facts that sit on the table or are we to accept stubbo's excuse's . i would also bet Robbie has the better record and that's without skooshing the league last year in a canter .

i dont give a damn about hibs managers records

[alwaysthereinspirit]

i dont give a damn about hibs managers records

I thought you were done posting?

[Prince Buaben]

The best Hibs Managers by their win %

 

1    Eddie Turnbull from 1971-72 to 1978-79 P21 L2 D7 W12 L9.52% D33.33% W57.14% A17 F37

2    Alex McLeish from 1997-98 to 2001-02 P10 L1 D4 W5 L10.00% D40.00% W50.00% A9 F19

3    Alex Maley from 1920-21 to 1924-25 P10 L2 D3 W5 L20.00% D30.00% W50.00% A14 F16

4    Jock Stein from 1964-65 to 1964-65 P4 L1 D1 W2 L25.00% D25.00% W50.00% A7 F9

5    William McCartney from 1936-37 to 1947-48 P29 L11 D4 W14 L37.93% D13.79% W48.28% A55 F62

6    Bob Shankly from 1965-66 to 1968-69 P9 L3 D2 W4 L33.33% D22.22% W44.44% A10 F16

7    Mika-Matti Petteri Paatelainen from 2007-08 to 2008-09 P6 L2 D2 W2 L33.33% D33.33% W33.33% A4 F3

8    Not Applicable from 1877-78 to 1902-03 P30 L12 D8 W10 L40.00% D26.67% W33.33% A49 F47

9    Tony Mowbray from 2004-05 to 2005-06 P9 L4 D2 W3 L44.44% D22.22% W33.33% A19 F11

10    John Collins from 2006-07 to 2007-08 P6 L3 D1 W2 L50.00% D16.67% W33.33% A7 F5

11    Hugh Shaw from 1948-49 to 1961-62 P31 L20 D3 W8 L64.52% D9.68% W25.81% A81 F46

12    Alan Stubbs from 2014-15 to 2014-15 P4 L1 D2 W1 L25.00% D50.00% W25.00% A4 F5

13    Pat Fenlon from 2011-12 to 2013-14 P10 L5 D3 W2 L50.00% D30.00% W20.00% A14 F6

14    Bobby Templeton from 1925-26 to 1935-36 P21 L6 D11 W4 L28.57% D52.38% W19.05% A40 F28

15    Alex Miller from 1986-87 to 1996-97 P40 L18 D15 W7 L45.00% D37.50% W17.50% A51 F32

16    Bobby Williamson from 2001-02 to 2003-04 P7 L4 D2 W1 L57.14% D28.57% W14.29% A16 F9

16    Walter Galbraith from 1961-62 to 1963-64 P7 L4 D2 W1 L57.14% D28.57% W14.29% A19 F10

18    Dan McMichael from 1903-04 to 1918-19 P36 L26 D5 W5 L72.22% D13.89% W13.89% A70 F29

19    Pat Stanton from 1983-84 to 1984-85 P5 L2 D3 W0 L40.00% D60.00% W0.00% A7 F5

20    John [8] Hughes from 2009-10 to 2009-10 P4 L2 D2 W0 L50.00% D50.00% W0.00% A5 F3

21    John Blackley from 1984-85 to 1986-87 P9 L5 D4 W0 L55.56% D44.44% W0.00% A15 F8

22    Colin Calderwood from 2010-11 to 2011-12 P4 L3 D1 W0 L75.00% D25.00% W0.00% A7 F2

23    James Duffy from 1996-97 to 1997-98 P5 L4 D1 W0 L80.00% D20.00% W0.00% A10 F2

 

Not Applicable has a better record than most of HIbs managers in the last 30 years

[vegas-voss]

some managers just have it when it comes to derbies but i dont think Robbie is one of them....what are his stats?

No offence but surely you can work it out seeing as he only played each other 4 times last season.

[Bigteam]

No offence but surely you can work it out seeing as he only played each other 4 times last season.

it was his stats compared to other hearts managers i wanted (and eventually got) - obviously didnt word it properly!!

[Bigteam]

I thought you were done posting?

i was until some sensible answers started coming through .......looks like the arseholes are back now though. Chow

[Mcalford]

Managers in 4 Derbies or more

 

Ranked by Loss %

 

Tommy Walker worse than Robbie!

 

1    Paulo Sergio from 2011-12 to 2011-12 P4 W4 D0 L0 W100.00% D0.00% L0.00% F12 A2

2    Sandy Clark from 1993-94 to 1993-94 P5 W3 D2 L0 W60.00% D40.00% L0.00% F6 A2

3    Peter Fairley from 1901-02 to 1902-03 P4 W2 D2 L0 W50.00% D50.00% L0.00% F5 A3

3    David Pratt from 1935-36 to 1936-37 P4 W2 D2 L0 W50.00% D50.00% L0.00% F15 A9

5    Joe Jordan from 1990-91 to 1992-93 P11 W5 D6 L0 W45.45% D54.55% L0.00% F14 A6

6    Alex MacDonald from 1983-84 to 1989-90 P28 W13 D12 L3 W46.43% D42.86% L10.71% F37 A24

7    Lindsay Waugh from 1903-04 to 1907-08 P9 W7 D1 L1 W77.78% D11.11% L11.11% F18 A8

8    John McCartney from 1909-10 to 1919-20 P23 W17 D3 L3 W73.91% D13.04% L13.04% F48 A19

9    Craig Levein from 2000-01 to 2004-05 P12 W5 D5 L2 W41.67% D41.67% L16.67% F21 A14

10    Jim Jefferies from 1995-96 to 2010-11 P23 W11 D7 L5 W47.83% D30.43% L21.74% F35 A29

11    Anatoly Korobochka from 2006-07 to 2007-08 P4 W2 D1 L1 W50.00% D25.00% L25.00% F4 A2

11    Valdas Ivanauskas from 2005-06 to 2006-07 P4 W2 D1 L1 W50.00% D25.00% L25.00% F10 A6

13    Robbie Neilson from 2014-15 to 2014-15 P4 W1 D2 L1 W25.00% D50.00% L25.00% F4 A5

14    Gary Locke from 2012-13 to 2013-14 P7 W4 D1 L2 W57.14% D14.29% L28.57% F8 A5

15    Csaba Laszlo from 2008-09 to 2009-10 P7 W1 D4 L2 W14.29% D57.14% L28.57% F4 A4

16    Tommy Walker from 1951-52 to 1966-67 P40 W22 D6 L12 W55.00% D15.00% L30.00% F99 A66

17    Frank Moss from 1937-38 to 1939-40 P6 W3 D1 L2 W50.00% D16.67% L33.33% F15 A14

18    William McCartney from 1919-20 to 1934-35 P30 W7 D13 L10 W23.33% D43.33% L33.33% F46 A43

19    John Harvey from 1966-67 to 1970-71 P8 W1 D4 L3 W12.50% D50.00% L37.50% F4 A8

20    Committee from 1877-78 to 1900-01 P26 W10 D6 L10 W38.46% D23.08% L38.46% F44 A44

21    William Esplin Ormond from 1978-79 to 1978-79 P5 W1 D2 L2 W20.00% D40.00% L40.00% F6 A7

22    David McLean from 1941-42 to 1950-51 P23 W11 D2 L10 W47.83% D8.70% L43.48% F37 A40

23    John Hagart from 1974-75 to 1976-77 P9 W0 D4 L5 W0.00% D44.44% L55.56% F5 A13

24    Caretaker from 1907-08 to 2005-06 P8 W3 D0 L5 W37.50% D0.00% L62.50% F16 A16

25    Bobby Seith from 1970-71 to 1974-75 P9 W1 D2 L6 W11.11% D22.22% L66.67% F7 A19

26    Tommy McLean from 1994-95 to 1994-95 P4 W1 D0 L3 W25.00% D0.00% L75.00% F4 A6

Never realised that after 22 in a row we were so bad in the 94-95 season, thankfully it never lasted for much longer.

[eddiepolio]

some managers just have it when it comes to derbies but i dont think Robbie is one of them....what are his stats?

Robbie's big game stats/performances definitely deserve some scrutiny........

Thankfully, we're just playing some gash wee championship team on Sunday so the usual hammering should be a formality!

[alwaysthereinspirit]

i was until some sensible answers started coming through .......looks like the arseholes are back now though. Chow

Why the bitterness? I don't go on to your team board in order to pick on you. You've really hurt my feeling.

[Nookie Bear]

Alex MacDonald from 1983-84 to 1989-90 P28 W13 D12 L3 W46.43% D42.86% L10.71% F37 A24

 

If ever there was a reason to have this man back for a half-time appearance, this is it.

[Bigteam]

Why the bitterness? I don't go on to your team board in order to pick on you. You've really hurt my feeling.

you are on my teamboard!!

[EreWeG0..]

some managers just have it when it comes to derbies but i dont think Robbie is one of them....what are his stats?

He'll get another win this weekend to improve his stats.

 

Hibs are inbred pish bottlers,as you will agree.

 

[Oneneilberry]

Chow ?

[queensferryjambo]

his record is exactly the same as Stubbs, 

 

 

however Robbie does have a trophy and winners medal, something stubbs will never have 

 

 

deal with it hibs 

 

 

Robbie also has a Scottish Cup Winners medal playing for an Edinburgh club - which is more than any living H1b5 player has. 

 

What a tackle Robbie

[Bazzas right boot]

He's managed 4 derbys

 

As a Hearts fan ( and even maybe a clued up Hibs fan)you would know this, to ask the question indicates you do not know this ( or are being sarcastic), questioning your football colours.

 

I don't call anyone a Hibs fan, but if you do not know this, I'm calling you out.

 

btw, this doesn't count as a big game for us ( important, yes), you are in the championship, the big game was last round and will be in the semi/ final when we play Celtic or another Prem side.

[Bazzas right boot]

The best Hibs Managers by their win %

 

1    Eddie Turnbull from 1971-72 to 1978-79 P21 L2 D7 W12 L9.52% D33.33% W57.14% A17 F37

2    Alex McLeish from 1997-98 to 2001-02 P10 L1 D4 W5 L10.00% D40.00% W50.00% A9 F19

3    Alex Maley from 1920-21 to 1924-25 P10 L2 D3 W5 L20.00% D30.00% W50.00% A14 F16

4    Jock Stein from 1964-65 to 1964-65 P4 L1 D1 W2 L25.00% D25.00% W50.00% A7 F9

5    William McCartney from 1936-37 to 1947-48 P29 L11 D4 W14 L37.93% D13.79% W48.28% A55 F62

6    Bob Shankly from 1965-66 to 1968-69 P9 L3 D2 W4 L33.33% D22.22% W44.44% A10 F16

7    Mika-Matti Petteri Paatelainen from 2007-08 to 2008-09 P6 L2 D2 W2 L33.33% D33.33% W33.33% A4 F3

8    Not Applicable from 1877-78 to 1902-03 P30 L12 D8 W10 L40.00% D26.67% W33.33% A49 F47

9    Tony Mowbray from 2004-05 to 2005-06 P9 L4 D2 W3 L44.44% D22.22% W33.33% A19 F11

10    John Collins from 2006-07 to 2007-08 P6 L3 D1 W2 L50.00% D16.67% W33.33% A7 F5

11    Hugh Shaw from 1948-49 to 1961-62 P31 L20 D3 W8 L64.52% D9.68% W25.81% A81 F46

12    Alan Stubbs from 2014-15 to 2014-15 P4 L1 D2 W1 L25.00% D50.00% W25.00% A4 F5

13    Pat Fenlon from 2011-12 to 2013-14 P10 L5 D3 W2 L50.00% D30.00% W20.00% A14 F6

14    Bobby Templeton from 1925-26 to 1935-36 P21 L6 D11 W4 L28.57% D52.38% W19.05% A40 F28

15    Alex Miller from 1986-87 to 1996-97 P40 L18 D15 W7 L45.00% D37.50% W17.50% A51 F32

16    Bobby Williamson from 2001-02 to 2003-04 P7 L4 D2 W1 L57.14% D28.57% W14.29% A16 F9

16    Walter Galbraith from 1961-62 to 1963-64 P7 L4 D2 W1 L57.14% D28.57% W14.29% A19 F10

18    Dan McMichael from 1903-04 to 1918-19 P36 L26 D5 W5 L72.22% D13.89% W13.89% A70 F29

19    Pat Stanton from 1983-84 to 1984-85 P5 L2 D3 W0 L40.00% D60.00% W0.00% A7 F5

20    John [8] Hughes from 2009-10 to 2009-10 P4 L2 D2 W0 L50.00% D50.00% W0.00% A5 F3

21    John Blackley from 1984-85 to 1986-87 P9 L5 D4 W0 L55.56% D44.44% W0.00% A15 F8

22    Colin Calderwood from 2010-11 to 2011-12 P4 L3 D1 W0 L75.00% D25.00% W0.00% A7 F2

23    James Duffy from 1996-97 to 1997-98 P5 L4 D1 W0 L80.00% D20.00% W0.00% A10 F2

 

 

The 70's was a dull one for us, anyone remember this, I can only ever remember us having the upper hand over them, late 80's onwards.

[TurboT]

Chow ?

i was thinking the same[emoji106]

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Bauld]

Last season Robbie prioritised not losing these games to keep our unbeaten run going knowing that it was the momentum we had built up that could be used as a source of motivation to drive us to winning the league as soon as possible.

 

 

This game is winner takes all. A draw doesn't suit either team. Hibs need to focus on the league and we don't want to go to easter road with a chance of securing third the priority.

 

 

Robbie will want this game done from the off.

[Bigteam]

He's managed 4 derbys

 

As a Hearts fan ( and even maybe a clued up Hibs fan)you would know this, to ask the question indicates you do not know this ( or are being sarcastic), questioning your football colours.

 

I don't call anyone a Hibs fan, but if you do not know this, I'm calling you out.

 

btw, this doesn't count as a big game for us ( important, yes), you are in the championship, the big game was last round and will be in the semi/ final when we play Celtic or another Prem side.

 mistake i have made is in title of thread it should be

What is Robbie's record in Derbies as a manager compared to other hearts managers

 but thankfully i got some sensible replies instead of accusations and got the answer

[Stuart G]

The 70's was a dull one for us, anyone remember this, I can only ever remember us having the upper hand over them, late 80's onwards.

Yes, 70s were murder,they had much the better of us, I was 16 the first time I saw us win at ER, 2-1 in 78, although we did only play twice a season, things started to swing slightly late 70s and then from 80s onward we have pretty much dominated.

[Joey J J Jr Shabadoo]

you are on my teamboard!!

Hearts fans knew what last season's Derby scores were.

[The Future's Maroon]

im a season ticket holder and my son plays at hearts. Due to the very nature of my son playing at hearts means i can hardly get to games as he plays on a saturday. Saying that next time i will just look up the facts my self  rather than ask the experst on here to try to get an opinion on what fans think of the managers derby record thus far

 

As I said, and others have its more how you put your question that had Hibs troll written all over it.

 

No need to throw the toys out the pram.

 

We are a friendly bunch here....and what you were TRYING to ask has now been answered a few posts above.

[Boyces beard]

i am being 100% genuine so no need for the smart arse comments and i agree with PTBCAL  i am unsure about his big game management. One of the draws was down to  Oz's late wonder strike but  to answer my question he has won once out of four games so his record is not the best

Why ask the question if you already know the answer, away you go before i get out my 51 inch maroon headed custard spitter and ram it up your hibby stink pipe.

[punkrockcroc]

Failure to get promoted again.

Stubbsy walks.

Ian Murray becomes manager.

7000 fans becomes 4000 fans.

Relegated to div 1.

Hibs end (not liquidated - they just all give up).

Ideal.

[Bigteam]

Hearts fans knew what last season's Derby scores were.

yes and that is why i admitted i badly worded the thread title  

[Bigteam]

As I said, and others have its more how you put your question that had Hibs troll written all over it.

 

No need to throw the toys out the pram.

 

We are a friendly bunch here....and what you were TRYING to ask has now been answered a few posts above.

to be fair only you and one other pointed out it was badly phrased question (which i agree)...the majority jump on the "you must be hibby" bandwagon

[Prince Buaben]

Hearts fans knew what last season's Derby scores were.

 

Hibs fans should too

[the big show]

i dont give a damn about hibs managers records

So for what reason would you be worried about ROBBIE'S given that it is far better than stubbo's when it comes to winning in big games or games that matter ? ffs i have heard of digging a hole or painting a picture but how obvious do you wan't to make it .

[Bigteam]

So for what reason would you be worried about ROBBIE'S given that it is far better than stubbo's when it comes to winning in big games or games that matter ? ffs i have heard of digging a hole or painting a picture but how obvious do you wan't to make it .

ok thicko so for the umpteenth time - i am comparing robbies record to other hearts managers .....f all to do with hibs managers. and it would seem in is short career thus far his record is not great!! 

[@VladMagic]

This thread has "potential" to be a classic

[The Treasurer]

im a season ticket holder and my son plays at hearts. Due to the very nature of my son playing at hearts means i can hardly get to games as he plays on a saturday. Saying that next time i will just look up the facts my self  rather than ask the experst on here to try to get an opinion on what fans think of the managers derby record thus far

Writes Hearts with a small h

 

PHM would NEVER make that schoolboy error.

[alwaysthereinspirit]

ok thicko so for the umpteenth time - i am comparing robbies record to other hearts managers .....f all to do with hibs managers. and it would seem in is short career thus far his record is not great!!

Three hours ago you were saying "chow"

[Dalstonjambo]

ok thicko so for the umpteenth time - i am comparing robbies record to other hearts managers .....f all to do with hibs managers. and it would seem in is short career thus far his record is not great!!

I'd be careful about using the word thicko when you said 'chow' pal

[Dalstonjambo]

Three hours ago you were saying "chow"

Ah sorry. Great minds

[The Future's Maroon]

to be fair only you and one other pointed out it was badly phrased question (which i agree)...the majority jump on the "you must be hibby" bandwagon

 

I don't doubt many posters, I don't doubt you myself anymore (yes, I did)....your small post count will always go against you...it did when I first joined.

 

And yes their is a bandwagon as you descibe, its what happens when there IS a lot of interlopers - usually around Derby time.

 

Anyways, glad you got your answer and stick around and contribute to the forum.

[Bigteam]

I don't doubt many posters, I don't doubt you myself anymore (yes, I did)....your small post count will always go against you...it did when I first joined.

 

And yes their is a bandwagon as you descibe, its what happens when there IS a lot of interlopers - usually around Derby time.

 

Anyways, glad you got your answer and stick around and contribute to the forum.

thanks and hopefully Robbies derby record will have improved come Sunday afternoon!

[Eldar Hadzimehmedovic]

It's a big game for Robbie in the sense everything rests on how we approach it. If we play like the Aberdeen and Motherwell games, even at their best Hibs just can't match that and we'll win easily. If we're pedestrian and dithering and let them have lots of the ball we could be in trouble.

 

Edit - tbf I think we've already addressed that sluggishness by ditching Gomis and two wingers and instead having Reilly stretch the defenders, allowing Djoum to get forward.