jamborich Posted November 1 Share Posted November 1 How many mistakes does this guy make in the box, my opinion is he loves the attention he doesn't give a hoot whether he's right or wrong but wollows in controversy Quote Link to post Share on other sites
Gorgie Boot boy Posted November 1 Share Posted November 1 Dick shaft more like. Quote Link to post Share on other sites
H2 Posted November 1 Share Posted November 1 I thought generally he had a good game, lack of support from his other officials. Quote Link to post Share on other sites
Cruickshank for Scotland Posted November 1 Share Posted November 1 He got the Hibs penalty wrong but apart from that I thought he was ok. My fear is that we will have Beaton or Madden for the final. Quote Link to post Share on other sites
cosanostra Posted November 1 Share Posted November 1 It was an odd performance but fair in that he was pretty crazy for both teams. Quote Link to post Share on other sites
1971fozzy Posted November 1 Share Posted November 1 He got their injury time one right. He got their extra time one wrong. He got our extra time one right 2/3 Quote Link to post Share on other sites
jamborich Posted November 1 Author Share Posted November 1 2 minutes ago, 1971fozzy said: He got their injury time one right. He got their extra time one wrong. He got our extra time one right 2/3 Did he get last years cup final one right? Quote Link to post Share on other sites
1971fozzy Posted November 1 Share Posted November 1 Just now, jamborich said: Did he get last years cup final one right? Of course he didn’t . Wasn’t the question though was it Quote Link to post Share on other sites
Bull's-eye Posted November 1 Share Posted November 1 He's consistent. Horrendous for both sides. Hibs penalty should have been picked up as blatant cheating by Madden, no surprise he ignored it. Quote Link to post Share on other sites
jamborich Posted November 1 Author Share Posted November 1 Just now, 1971fozzy said: Of course he didn’t . Wasn’t the question though was it Yes it was Quote Link to post Share on other sites
1971fozzy Posted November 1 Share Posted November 1 Just now, jamborich said: Yes it was what are you on about ? He rightly refused their dive in 90, he feked up and got their ET one wrong, and ours was a pen. Who the fek was talking about celtics last season ? (Which incidentally I said wasn’t) what are u on about ? Quote Link to post Share on other sites
bajthejambo Posted November 1 Share Posted November 1 They're not happy with the officials even though their goal was offside and Newell dived for their penalty. What more did they expect? Quote Link to post Share on other sites
JamTarts98 Posted November 1 Share Posted November 1 23 minutes ago, H2 said: I thought generally he had a good game, lack of support from his other officials. Agreed entirely for their awarded penalty in extra time. It looked like both the linesman and the behind goal line linesman (I'm old, sod off) had a great clear view. It was a clear dive so there is no point having extra officials. Quote Link to post Share on other sites
Maple Leaf Posted November 1 Share Posted November 1 He had an OK game. The vermin goal was offside, but that was on the linesman, not Collum. Quote Link to post Share on other sites
Gone Posted November 1 Share Posted November 1 He's had a shocker in his last 3 fixtures. Aberdeen Celtic - Couple of iffy pens and missed a blatant shove for Celtics equaliser Slavia Leverkusen - Sent a guy off when there was no contact Today - Not convinced ours or theres were penalties Hopeless referee Quote Link to post Share on other sites
AGoodLaugh Posted November 1 Share Posted November 1 Have you seen the red card he gave against Leverkusen on Thursday? Good to see he's an attention seeker on the European stage as well, I guess. Quote Link to post Share on other sites
Thommo414 Posted November 1 Share Posted November 1 A shit referee all round imo. Not clever enough to be deliberate or manipulative in anything he does, just grossly incompetent Quote Link to post Share on other sites
Bunny Munro Posted November 1 Share Posted November 1 I thought there was 2 incredibly soft penalty shouts per team. He gave one each and ignored one each. I don't think any of them were penalties really. The worst bit of decision making was not flagging offside for their goal. There was a few dodgy offside calls in the game but that was the only one that looked like it was going to make a difference. Quote Link to post Share on other sites
Cade Posted November 1 Share Posted November 1 Not sure he'd have given ours if he hadn't already given them one for a blatant dive........ He's a useless wee fud and always has been. Quote Link to post Share on other sites
Dallas Green Posted November 1 Share Posted November 1 Thought he was his usual self. Which is a pish ref. Quote Link to post Share on other sites
Hungry hippo Posted November 1 Share Posted November 1 The guy is addicted to awarding penalties. Quote Link to post Share on other sites
jamborich Posted November 1 Author Share Posted November 1 1 hour ago, 1971fozzy said: what are you on about ? He rightly refused their dive in 90, he feked up and got their ET one wrong, and ours was a pen. Who the fek was talking about celtics last season ? (Which incidentally I said wasn’t) what are u on about ? I'm on about his obsession with penalties not just today but in general he appears imo to thrive on them Quote Link to post Share on other sites
alwaysthereinspirit Posted November 1 Share Posted November 1 It was a dive. So he either guessed or cheated. Because there was no trip. Quote Link to post Share on other sites
1971fozzy Posted November 1 Share Posted November 1 59 minutes ago, jamborich said: I'm on about his obsession with penalties not just today but in general he appears imo to thrive on them Ahh fair enough Quote Link to post Share on other sites
Jambo_Jarman Posted November 1 Share Posted November 1 I thought we got away with one at the end of normal time, though I'd need to see it again. Not the Boyle one, he fouled Halkett and then made a meal of it, but the initial challenge on Doidge. Their ET penalty was a dive from a tory pr!ck that should've been picked up by Madden - Collum didn't have a good angle. As for ours, I don't think it was a pen as both were just running on to the ball and I thought White just positioned himself in front of McGinn, who ran into him, but we deserved it on the rule of karma due to that diving Tory pr!ck. **** Joe Newell. Quote Link to post Share on other sites
A_A wehatethehibs Posted November 1 Share Posted November 1 (edited) Listen at the end of the day he gave Hearts the penalty to win it so far as I'm concerned, all is not forgiven he is still a ***** for giving that Edouard dive. Always will be. As for the decisions last night Hibs was a clear dive and the fud that took their penalty knew it. Our penalty was an absolute Stone Waller, Sir Aidrian White had the boy on toast for pace. Quintessential clumsy hibs defending. Edited November 1 by A_A wehatethehibs Quote Link to post Share on other sites
ri Alban Posted November 1 Share Posted November 1 4 hours ago, H2 said: I thought generally he had a good game, lack of support from his other officials. This. The refs behind the goal line were useless. Quote Link to post Share on other sites
iantjambo Posted November 1 Share Posted November 1 Both penalties were very soft. Quote Link to post Share on other sites
Harry Potter Posted November 1 Share Posted November 1 5 hours ago, jamborich said: How many mistakes does this guy make in the box, my opinion is he loves the attention he doesn't give a hoot whether he's right or wrong but wollows in controversy Hes a clown, some said he had improved, dont think so. Could have cost us the game, said to my son before the game, he will give them a penalty. Not hard to predict.😠. Quote Link to post Share on other sites
Sherbet Posted November 1 Share Posted November 1 1 hour ago, iantjambo said: Both penalties were very soft. Ours was debatable theirs was no debate it was a dive Quote Link to post Share on other sites
iantjambo Posted November 1 Share Posted November 1 1 minute ago, Sherbet said: Ours was debatable theirs was no debate it was a dive I’ll take that 😁 Quote Link to post Share on other sites
allystrachan Posted November 1 Share Posted November 1 To be fair to him on their dive his angle may not have been the best but Bobby Madden’s view must have been pretty good. I have seen softer pens given than ours too. Mcginn’s left arm is certainly pushing White putting him off balance whether he meant to trip him or not. End of the day the defender clattered the attacker in the box & that’s a pen nine times out of ten. Quote Link to post Share on other sites
smiler Posted November 1 Share Posted November 1 Some of you are being a bit harsh on Collum, he’s really good at running backwards. Quote Link to post Share on other sites
smiler Posted November 1 Share Posted November 1 Tbh our penalty looked a soft one, I never saw theirs but I’d have been raging if it was the othe way about. Quote Link to post Share on other sites
Selkirkhmfc1874 Posted November 1 Share Posted November 1 Absolutely bricked it in final minute of normal time because thought he gave them a penalty at first Quote Link to post Share on other sites
Sooperstar Posted November 1 Share Posted November 1 6 hours ago, Cruickshank for Scotland said: He got the Hibs penalty wrong but apart from that I thought he was ok. My fear is that we will have Beaton or Madden for the final. Madden was right on the line with their penalty claim during normal time. Commentator reckoned Collum was going to give it barring Madden's involvement. We got a free kick. Quote Link to post Share on other sites
Harry Potter Posted November 1 Share Posted November 1 Hibs goal was offside, down to the linesman but collum has the last word. Quote Link to post Share on other sites
Deevers Posted November 1 Share Posted November 1 If we get Celtic in the final I wonder if they’ll give the fixture to Clancy. Quote Link to post Share on other sites
Saughton Jambo Posted November 1 Share Posted November 1 6 hours ago, jamborich said: I'm on about his obsession with penalties not just today but in general he appears imo to thrive on them Especially when games are televised live. He thrives in the spotlight and does it for attention as he knows the cameras are in him. Probably records the games and then goes home to watch himself numerous times on rewind. Quote Link to post Share on other sites
Rogue Daddy Posted November 1 Share Posted November 1 My main gripe with him was how many fouls Gogic got away with! Eventually (after foul 27) he got a yellow card and Ross took him off immediately! Hubz pen was a clear dive, ours was soft but at least there was contact and White was ahead of the defender. Apart from that, he did ok. Quote Link to post Share on other sites
RobNox Posted November 1 Share Posted November 1 7 hours ago, Gone said: He's had a shocker in his last 3 fixtures. Aberdeen Celtic - Couple of iffy pens and missed a blatant shove for Celtics equaliser Slavia Leverkusen - Sent a guy off when there was no contact Today - Not convinced ours or theres were penalties Hopeless referee I agree, I'm not convinced either of those incidents were penalties. However, at least he was consistent and awarded both sides a dodgy penalty. It's not his fault that one penalty taker stuck it away comfortably, while the other Hibsd it. Quote Link to post Share on other sites
Mid Calder Jambo Posted November 1 Share Posted November 1 1 hour ago, Sooperstar said: Madden was right on the line with their penalty claim during normal time. Commentator reckoned Collum was going to give it barring Madden's involvement. We got a free kick. Yes Ibrox Madden saved us. It was a stonewaller that one. Quote Link to post Share on other sites
Nookie Bear Posted November 1 Share Posted November 1 3 minutes ago, Mid Calder Jambo said: Yes Ibrox Madden saved us. It was a stonewaller that one. I thought the initial ball was offside but yes, I thought he was going to give it. Quote Link to post Share on other sites
GMEdinburgh Posted November 1 Share Posted November 1 (edited) Madden also looked like he was pointing to the spot for the penalty that was given as well in the TV angle from Collums View. Edited November 1 by GMEdinburgh Quote Link to post Share on other sites
The Real Maroonblood Posted November 1 Share Posted November 1 Great referee. Quote Link to post Share on other sites
FWJ Posted November 1 Share Posted November 1 37 minutes ago, Saughton Jambo said: Especially when games are televised live. He thrives in the spotlight and does it for attention as he knows the cameras are in him. Probably records the games and then goes home to watch himself numerous times on rewind. Yup A high-profile cup semi-final between two well known rivals at the national stadium and, guess what, the talking points are all about the ref. Good old Willie. Quote Link to post Share on other sites
Doc Rob Posted November 1 Share Posted November 1 TBH both penalties were pretty crap. The Hibs one was dodgier though - unless I am very much mistaken, Popescu actually pulls out of the challenge at the last moment and the Hibs player goes flying anyway. Quote Link to post Share on other sites
Jambo92 Posted November 1 Share Posted November 1 Its nothing new, do everything possible to stop giving Collum the chance to give a penalty. Popescu gave him the opportunity and it was taken. Still not seen a good angle of the injury time penalty shout, alot of pundits taking a guess at it but looks to me that Doidge goes looking for it and right under the nose of Madden. Quote Link to post Share on other sites
BelgeJambo Posted November 1 Share Posted November 1 4 minutes ago, The Real Maroonblood said: Great referee. This 😂😂😜😜 🇱🇻🇱🇻🇱🇻 Quote Link to post Share on other sites
Jambo_Lambo Posted November 1 Share Posted November 1 Was it not Collum that gave Celtic that dubious penalty at Murrayfield too? That prick Christie if my memory serves me correctly? Quote Link to post Share on other sites
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.