What a transfer window!!

[James1874f]

9 hours ago, RobNox said:

 

Good point, he will seem like a new player.  You could also add Godinho when he returns from injury, as he wasn't an established first teamer last season, unlike Brandon, who will also hopefully be back from injury in a couple of months.

Godinho I had forgotten about him !  I liked the look of him be good to see him in this side. Exciting times this season

[Bazzas right boot]

4 hours ago, Pasquale for King said:

Bit negative for you mate, Edwards isn’t great and Bozanic looks a bit ponderous, Mulraney has a lot to learn and Burns needs nurturing but the signs are good.

 

 

He he. 

I think we have improved v last year in quality, balance and depth. No doubt. 

But, by how much? 

Think the jury is out on most tho at this early stage, although the signs are encouraging. 

 

Many of the new guys are unproven in Scotland, and a good start although great, doesn't mean that we should be hailing signings as a overall success. 

 

Too often we write players off or hail them as God's far too early. It's a theme on here. 

 

Very good start,although it's what I expected under Craig tbh. 

 

As you say, signs are good! 

 

After 10 games I'll be better placed to judge. 

 

Not negative, balanced?

[davie1980]

10 hours ago, karipidis said:

When Hearts make signings we are looking at maybe a 50% success rate, out of the 16 I’d say we are looking at 9 very good signings 6 potentially very good/jury’s out and 1 not so good. That’s an incredibly good window.

 

Ins,

1. Steven MacLean. Very good signing  (started well/too old/nothing left to offer)

2. Uche ikpeazu. Very good signing (Big huddie, won't hit 20 goal mark)

3. Bobby burns. Potentially very good (not fulfilling potential, at 19 should be first team starter, empty him)

4. Jake mulraney. Jury’s out/potential (never a football player, kick and run expert)

5. Olly Lee. Very good signing (Decent player, not Hartley/Cameron/Fulton type player that we need)

6. Ben garuccio. Very good signing (I said we should have kept Eckersly)

7. Zdenek zlamal. Very good signing (Good shot stopper, too erratic/distribution not good enough)

8. Ryan Edwards. Not so good (Couldn't get a game for Edinburgh city)

9. Oliver bozanic. Jury’s out/potential (Another mercenary/wage feef)

12. Kevin silva. potential (Never going to make the first team, empty now)

13. Colin Doyle. Jury’s out/potentially a good signing (Never going to make the first team, old duffer, waste of money)

14. Jimmy Dunne. Very good signing (**once Berra comes back** Reserve team player at best)

16. Craig wighton. Jury’s out/potentially very good (not quick enough, not a 20 goal striker, modern day Callum Elliot)

 

Added comments as per the JKB view 6 months from now

 

Pre-empting signings

McAuley - Can't last 90 minutes for 38 games a season

Vanacek - This years Tullberg/Wittenveen/Makela

Edited August 31, 2018 by davie1980

[Pasquale for King]

2 hours ago, WeeChuck'sHeed said:

 

 

He he. 

I think we have improved v last year in quality, balance and depth. No doubt. 

But, by how much? 

Think the jury is out on most tho at this early stage, although the signs are encouraging. 

 

Many of the new guys are unproven in Scotland, and a good start although great, doesn't mean that we should be hailing signings as a overall success. 

 

Too often we write players off or hail them as God's far too early. It's a theme on here. 

 

Very good start,although it's what I expected under Craig tbh. 

 

As you say, signs are good! 

 

After 10 games I'll be better placed to judge. 

 

Not negative, balanced?

Fair enough ??

[Andrew Gilbert Wauchope]

13 hours ago, been here before said:

 

But still available to be recalled however unlikely or should someone want to sign him we'd get any fee or if/when he leaves the money freed up comes off our wage bill.

 

So, effectively, he's still ours but on loan.

 

That's right, cheer me up .... ?