Tynecastle Valhalla Posted January 31, 2009 Share Posted January 31, 2009 Just back from the game: Macdonald - 5 - very little to do but let in two goals. Neilson - 4 - terrible performance, should not be in the team let alone our captain. not a pen tho. Jonsson - 4 - cant win headers, not a centre half. should play at right back. Zal - 4 - had his trademark bombscare moment - almost gifted them a goal. at least he won some headers. still think we should get rid. Wallace - 7 - thought he did reasonably well, got into some good positions going forward and relatively solid. Obua - 7 - played well, some nice touches/turns but a bit predictable. not much in the way of urgency. glad to see gradual improvement. Bruno - 6 - quiet game but showed some urgency, his passing ability is blatantly obvious, shouldnt have been subbed off. Karipidis - 5 - poor game today, inneffectual. should play at centre half or right back. Stewart- 7 - played ok, some good and bad points. at least he tried. would prefer ruben. Driver - 3 - another horrific away performance. doesnt turn up, no final ball, no confidence. hope he stays as he will improve his consistency. Nade - 6 - not his best game today. so slow. needs better service/support and was let down. Kingston - 4 - made some things happen when he came on. clearly got ability but a bad attitude. not sure where he was at half time. Glen - 3 - hardly involved. Elliot - 1 - worst player I have ever seen in SPL. I counted 2 fresh air shots. please bin him asap. We miss Ruben when he doesnt play - under-rated player. Berra was a huge miss in terms of his playing and captain ability, hope he doesnt go. looking forward to balogh being back in goals. the ref had a shocker for their penalty - also the hamilton striker was off-sideand the linesman kept the flag down. what was very apparent was a lack of drive/determination/urgency/fire in your belly. even when losing very few players seemed to care. we will never get into europe if we continue like that. we need more passion!! Hamilton were absolutely rubbish as well. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
captain Posted January 31, 2009 Share Posted January 31, 2009 Sadly it is hard to disagree with much of that. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
chester copperpot Posted January 31, 2009 Share Posted January 31, 2009 Everyone a 4, prob except Obua and Stewart. They would get 6.5. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Devries4 Posted January 31, 2009 Share Posted January 31, 2009 Just back from the game: Macdonald - 5 - very little to do but let in two goals. Neilson - 4 - terrible performance, should not be in the team let alone our captain. not a pen tho. Jonsson - 4 - cant win headers, not a centre half. should play at right back. Zal - 4 - had his trademark bombscare moment - almost gifted them a goal. at least he won some headers. still think we should get rid. Wallace - 7 - thought he did reasonably well, got into some good positions going forward and relatively solid. Obua - 7 - played well, some nice touches/turns but a bit predictable. not much in the way of urgency. glad to see gradual improvement. Bruno - 6 - quiet game but showed some urgency, his passing ability is blatantly obvious, shouldnt have been subbed off. Karipidis - 5 - poor game today, inneffectual. should play at centre half or right back. Stewart- 7 - played ok, some good and bad points. at least he tried. would prefer ruben. Driver - 3 - another horrific away performance. doesnt turn up, no final ball, no confidence. hope he stays as he will improve his consistency. Nade - 6 - not his best game today. so slow. needs better service/support and was let down. Kingston - 4 - made some things happen when he came on. clearly got ability but a bad attitude. not sure where he was at half time. Glen - 3 - hardly involved. Elliot - 1 - worst player I have ever seen in SPL. I counted 2 fresh air shots. please bin him asap. We miss Ruben when he doesnt play - under-rated player. Berra was a huge miss in terms of his playing and captain ability, hope he doesnt go. looking forward to balogh being back in goals. the ref had a shocker for their penalty - also the hamilton striker was off-sideand the linesman kept the flag down. what was very apparent was a lack of drive/determination/urgency/fire in your belly. even when losing very few players seemed to care. we will never get into europe if we continue like that. we need more passion!! Hamilton were absolutely rubbish as well. Yes Iwould agree with most of this. Bit unfair on Clum being the worst player in the SPL when the boy O'Brien is still at Hibs though. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
hearts_crazy Posted January 31, 2009 Share Posted January 31, 2009 I'd give everyone a 5 or 6. Obua gets a 7.5 from me though, I though he was head and shoulders above everyone else on the park today, barely put a foot wrong all day. It's amazing what a couple of goals can do for a player's confidence. Who was the plum who was giving him pelters all game BTW (left side of stand half way up) He even gave him verbal because he didn't happen to be standing on the particular square inch of turf that he wanted him to be. I note he didn't congratulate him on any of his good play either. Fair enough the guy has taken time to settle, but some folk really need to open their eyes and keep an open mind, he had a good game, I don't think many people could deny that. Who was the clown who phoned into Radio Scotland to say 'Csaba out' by the way. Jeez, get a grip eh. We lost, it happens, who's up next? Hamilton are gash BTW, jammy *******s too, scored with only real chance and got a penalty that should never have been given. I though that was the incident that took the wind out of our sails BTW, I reckon we would have done them had they not gone two up, they (Hamilton) offered sod all going forward and their 11-0-0 formation frustrated our forward players all game. Thank feck the teams around us had crap results too. Also how freezing was it today? Brrrrr. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Tynecastle Valhalla Posted January 31, 2009 Author Share Posted January 31, 2009 Yes Iwould agree with most of this. Bit unfair on Clum being the worst player in the SPL when the boy O'Brien is still at Hibs though. fair enough,prob right. i am just annoyed after game. hate getting beat. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
deejtee Posted January 31, 2009 Share Posted January 31, 2009 Pretty poor apart from Obua and Stewart. Macdonald does not give me confidence and Eggert cant play left side of central defence. Driver and Bruno contributed nothing today unfortunately. Penalty right in front of us was as soft as any I have ever seen and finished us and never felt we looked like breaking them down as they just sat back and we couldn't get in behind them. Subs were too late so Csaba gets a low mark this week. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
hearts_crazy Posted January 31, 2009 Share Posted January 31, 2009 Yes Iwould agree with most of this. Bit unfair on Clum being the worst player in the SPL when the boy O'Brien is still at Hibs though. Not so sure mind was it not him who had the shot near the end which probably ended up in Sainsbury's car park? That said I wouldn't expect him to score coming on so late. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Cupar Jambo Posted January 31, 2009 Share Posted January 31, 2009 Macdonald - 5 - Nothing to do Neilson - 5 - Not his best Jonsson - 4 - Cant win a header Zal - 4 - Poor Wallace - 7 - Thought he was one of the better ones Obua - 6 - OK, plenty first half ball but no end product Bruno - 5 - Quiet Karipidis - 5 - Poor game today Stewart- 7 - 100% as usual Driver - 3 - Another poor away game Nade - 5 - Poor, he is just not good enough Kingston - 3 Glen - 3 - Elliot - 1 - Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Coco Posted February 1, 2009 Share Posted February 1, 2009 Macdonald - 4 - too slight and short, does not convince Neilson - 5 - not at his best Der Kaiser - 4 - poor performance Jonsson - 3 - worst game for Hearts Wallace - 5 - little going forward Obua - 6 - getting better, bad for balance of the team though Stewart - 5 - poor Karipidis - 5 - poor Driver - 5 - totally outshone by Hamilton youngsters Aguiar - 4 - never in the game Nade - 4 - never in the game Kingston - 1 - useless Glen - 3 - not involved Elliot - 3 - at least tried to score A hopeless, gutless performance. Questions should be asked of Laszlo's inability to change a game. 2 nil down and still he refuses to change the dire setup of the team. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
20
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.