MAFIA - Let's save Christmas

[Boof]

5 minutes ago, Dunks said:

Stuart's own defence pointed to him having a role, so Bunny's suggestion that Stuart was a twin was a logical one. Doesn't mean Bunny was the other twin, but time will tell.

 

Good call, Dunks. Haven't been back for a look to see what Stuart was saying.

 

[Dunks]

I usually target lurkers after a day or two, but there are quite a few this game. The excuses so far deserve a vote, but I've only got one to give!

 

So let's hear you lurkers, why shouldn't we vote for you? 

[AlimOzturk]

14 minutes ago, Dunks said:

I usually target lurkers after a day or two, but there are quite a few this game. The excuses so far deserve a vote, but I've only got one to give!

 

So let's hear you lurkers, why shouldn't we vote for you? 

Riddley/Yvonne/Dawn sticking out as the biggest lurkers for me so far. 

[Boof]

22 hours ago, Stuart McNeill said:

Let's the hate flow through yous! 

 

 

Mwuahahahahahah! 

 

In Alims defence he always does vote me day 1. 

 

It's the other 2 you need to worry about. 

 

The other 2 being Yvonne (mason) and AndyNic (currently unknown - to me, anyway)

 

19 hours ago, Stuart McNeill said:

The goons have already won it. 

 

You and Yvonne to busy allowing me to live in your head. Rather than focusing on the goons. 

 

Unless Ofcourse you've hit the jackpot and you're both goons and you're now using the last game as an excuse to get a free kill.

 

 

A goon 3 games in a row? C'mon now behave. 

 

Vote #14 

 

Stuart subsequently shown to be not a goon. Ditto Yvonne.

 

19 hours ago, Stuart McNeill said:

Been done stinking here 😂😂😂😂😂

 

Must've been after 3rd vote - from AlimO

 

19 hours ago, Stuart McNeill said:

So just to confirm. 

 

Vote milky. 

 

 

Wasn't actually sure who 14 was. 

 

Possibly unlikely that milky is Stuart's brother, then...maybe?

 

16 hours ago, Shapes said:

I'm about to crack open a bottle of wine so if you think my counting is bad normally...

 

Might've needed something stronger the way that voting went  

 

16 hours ago, Stuart McNeill said:

Mate.... 

 

Youre playing mind games with yourself 😂

 

Just unvote me. No one will notice 

 

To AndyNic

 

16 hours ago, Stuart McNeill said:

Vote Boof 

 

I think Stuart was going into self-preservation mode now.

 

15 hours ago, Stuart McNeill said:

Thought I could trust you. 

 

Nae goons are helping, is the goon team even big enough? 😂 I need the goodies to do so. You said you would save me. Last min change yeah? 

 

To Sean.

 

15 hours ago, Stuart McNeill said:

 

 

'revenge' 

 

 

Aka free kill

 

Must've been to Yvonne and AndyNic.

 

15 hours ago, Boof said:

 

This is playing havoc with my spreadsheet.

 

According to it, Stuart still has an active vote on milky.

 

Can't do anything more with it until I get it sorted.

 

Just puts following Stuart posts into context.

 

14 hours ago, Stuart McNeill said:

Oh sorry Boof. 

 

I did mean to 

 

Unvote whoever it is 😭

 

14 hours ago, Stuart McNeill said:

Vote yvonne

 

14 hours ago, Stuart McNeill said:

Make it interesting

 

 

Put Yvonne in a tie 

 

To me, I think.

 

14 hours ago, Stuart McNeill said:

unvote  milky

 

14 hours ago, Stuart McNeill said:

if Seans Voting didn't. My blunders will have certainly done it

 

Reference to my spreadsheet catching fire  

 

14 hours ago, Stuart McNeill said:

vote dawn

 

Self-preservation time again, I think.

 

14 hours ago, Stuart McNeill said:

I believe we're not allowed to vote ourselves anymore unfortunately.

 

Anti-self-preservation time  

 

14 hours ago, Stuart McNeill said:

you voted me ?

 

14 hours ago, Stuart McNeill said:

have I seriously messed up again??

 

 

Get this day over with haha

 

And there we have it.

 

Now not all that sure where Dunks is reading the hint of a role... @Dunks...any help?

[AlimOzturk]

1 minute ago, Boof said:

 

The other 2 being Yvonne (mason) and AndyNic (currently unknown - to me, anyway)

 

 

Stuart subsequently shown to be not a goon. Ditto Yvonne.

 

 

Must've been after 3rd vote - from AlimO

 

 

Possibly unlikely that milky is Stuart's brother, then...maybe?

 

 

Might've needed something stronger the way that voting went  

 

 

To AndyNic

 

 

I think Stuart was going into self-preservation mode now.

 

 

To Sean.

 

 

Must've been to Yvonne and AndyNic.

 

 

Just puts following Stuart posts into context.

 

 

 

 

To me, I think.

 

 

 

Reference to my spreadsheet catching fire  

 

 

Self-preservation time again, I think.

 

 

Anti-self-preservation time  

 

 

 

And there we have it.

 

Now not all that sure where Dunks is reading the hint of a role... @Dunks...any help?

I am seeing desperation and trying to protect himself. If he was a townie then sacrificing himself to potentially save another roled player from being hit would have been the order of the day? 

[Boof]

3 minutes ago, AlimOzturk said:

I am seeing desperation and trying to protect himself. If he was a townie then sacrificing himself to potentially save another roled player from being hit would have been the order of the day? 

 

Is that enough?

 

Nobody wants to be first person lynched though. Even I had a mump at Sean for voting me and I'm completely expendable apart from (potentially wonky) theorising.

[iantjambo]

1 hour ago, Marvin said:

Morning folks, shame we lost Yvonne but we did get one the naughty kids.

Still tricky who to trust as a lot of votes from yesterday were based on little evidence. 

Sean did his usual opening day vote changes so nothing suspect there. I could go for one of the players voting Yvonne but they wouldn't have known she was a Mason.

So based on limited info so far...

Vote IanT not buying his hangover excuse - can't do the time then don't do the crime.

Pop over to the Terrace and you’ll see I only posted once on the match thread.

[iantjambo]

28 minutes ago, Dunks said:

I usually target lurkers after a day or two, but there are quite a few this game. The excuses so far deserve a vote, but I've only got one to give!

 

So let's hear you lurkers, why shouldn't we vote for you? 

Because you would be wasting a vote on me. Unless you’re a goon of course.

[Stuart McNeill]

Wooooooo 

 

 

Yvonne's dead? 

 

 

I'm devastated 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Wooooooooo

[milky_26]

16 minutes ago, AlimOzturk said:

Riddley/Yvonne/Dawn sticking out as the biggest lurkers for me so far. 

Erm, Yvonne was killed by the goons

[Bunny Munro]

49 minutes ago, Boof said:

 

Posted 2 minutes before deadline when there didn't seem to be any concerted effort to try to save Stuart.

 

This was my 'Ah...could Stuart be Bunny's other half?' moment.

 

So in the interests of starting a fight - could the real Stuart-partner step forward and we'll get rid of Bunny?

 

Doing so will make the real Stuart-other-half unvoteable due to their townliness and if the goons/naughty kids subsequently try to get rid then the town ought to appreciate the self-sacrifice since we're only losing a vanilla townie rather than a really good guy.

 

If nobody steps forward...does that mean Bunny has to be the now-good Aussie kid? And thus unvoteable - and perhaps worthy of some Doc-attention tonight? Is there anything I'm missing?

 

Surely nobody else would know about the naughty-kid pairings?

 

Sorry if I'm launching you under a bus, Bunny, but it's for the good of the town.

 

And if I'm barking up a completely wrong tree - that's not unusual for me  

 

Your thoughts, please...

 

 

 

No launching involved Boof, I said what i meant and I meant what I said.

 

I'm not sure I'd waste the Doc on a townie myself.

[Tenaciousdandy]

33 minutes ago, Boof said:

 

Good call, Dunks. Haven't been back for a look to see what Stuart was saying.

 

Didn't look like he was really saying much tbh, his lynching looked like a grudge from the previous game, both yvonne and andy saying so, will have to have a look at my spreadsheet and see who also voted for him and tried to possibly save him to see if we can get a clearer picture 

[Dunks]

9 minutes ago, AlimOzturk said:

I am seeing desperation and trying to protect himself. If he was a townie then sacrificing himself to potentially save another roled player from being hit would have been the order of the day? 

 

Exactly this. Seemed obvious to me he had a role that was neither mason or goon. 

[Bunny Munro]

It'll be interesting today to see who is still quiet.

There is more reasons to be quiet on a Saturday, plenty of other things going on.

 

 

[iantjambo]

Vote Marvin

 

Classic goon tactic of trying to put suspicion on an innocent player just because they had one quiet day.

 

 

[AndyNic]

1 hour ago, AlimOzturk said:

Worked out well the last games that strategy 😂

 

Never going to live that down 

 

[Tenaciousdandy]

unvote ian

Vote rudi

As smack (I think) said he's barely posted anything so maybe trying to go unnoticed 

[AndyNic]

17 minutes ago, Dandyman79 said:

Didn't look like he was really saying much tbh, his lynching looked like a grudge from the previous game, both yvonne and andy saying so, will have to have a look at my spreadsheet and see who also voted for him and tried to possibly save him to see if we can get a clearer picture 

 

My vote for Stuart was 100% this. I said I would vote for someone else if they stuck out but it was day 1 so was always going to be pure guesswork regardless.

[Dunks]

44 minutes ago, AlimOzturk said:

Riddley/Yvonne/Dawn sticking out as the biggest lurkers for me so far. 

 

26 minutes ago, milky_26 said:

Erm, Yvonne was killed by the goons

 

Nobody else seems to have picked this up.

 

[AlimOzturk]

3 minutes ago, Dunks said:

 

 

Nobody else seems to have picked this up.

 

Forgot she was taken out by the goons. Just goes to prove I am clearly not a goon!

[Tenaciousdandy]

1 minute ago, AlimOzturk said:

Forgot she was taken out by the goons. Just goes to prove I am clearly not a goon!

Or a goon tactic? altho I'm not sure you'd do that as it would be a pretty obvious one but never know

[Dr. Sheldon Cooper]

Afternoon.

 

Going out for lunch shortly and doing a few errands afterwards so I'll not be around for the next few hours, but will contribute when I get home.

[AndyNic]

33 minutes ago, AlimOzturk said:

Forgot she was taken out by the goons. Just goes to prove I am clearly not a goon!

 

Hmmm. How convenient.

 

 

 

[iantjambo]

35 minutes ago, AlimOzturk said:

Forgot she was taken out by the goons. Just goes to prove I am clearly not a goon!

Or is that what you want us to think?

 

[AndyNic]

Alim going all out to try get himself on the good list early in the game I see...

[Bunny Munro]

I'd say its a ballsy move from Alim if he is a goon.

Doesn't mean he isn't though.

[AndyNic]

Lowest post count (by my count) is:

 

Dawn 

Rudi

Ian

Morgaro

Milky

 

Who is the resident post counter?

 

 

[AndyNic]

2 minutes ago, AndyNic said:

Lowest post count (by my count) is:

 

Dawn 

Rudi

Ian

Morgaro

Milky

 

Who is the resident post counter?

 

 

 

Forgot about Riddley. He's hardly posted either. 

[Tenaciousdandy]

1 minute ago, AndyNic said:

Lowest post count (by my count) is:

 

Dawn 

Rudi

Ian

Morgaro

Milky

 

Who is the resident post counter?

 

 

I have done it in the past, will have a count when I get a minute 

[Boof]

1 hour ago, Bunny Munro said:

 

No launching involved Boof,

 

I suppose I just meant that if you're a known townie now, you'll be more of a target for the folk who want to keep waters muddied.

 

1 hour ago, Bunny Munro said:

I said what i meant and I meant what I said.

 

Spoken like a forthright, straight-talkin' Aussie, perhaps?

 

1 hour ago, Bunny Munro said:

I'm not sure I'd waste the Doc on a townie myself.

 

Very altruistic - good to keep the goons thinking.

 

Maybe more clarification from @Shapes... if two factions try to kill does a Doc-save work on both of 'em?

 

 

Also - any thoughts (from anyone) on the notion of cop/naughties working together - as far as possible - so that they don't end up investigating the same person?

 

i.e. Cop go for top half and naughties go for bottom half of player list? Or vice-versa - no odds to me.

[Riddley Walker]

Sorry folks, been a really hectic couple of days. Need to have a good look over the thread. Just a townie this time so looking forward to accusing folk.

 

 

[AndyNic]

8 minutes ago, Boof said:

 

I suppose I just meant that if you're a known townie now, you'll be more of a target for the folk who want to keep waters muddied.

 

 

Spoken like a forthright, straight-talkin' Aussie, perhaps?

 

 

Very altruistic - good to keep the goons thinking.

 

Maybe more clarification from @Shapes... if two factions try to kill does a Doc-save work on both of 'em?

 

 

Also - any thoughts (from anyone) on the notion of cop/naughties working together - as far as possible - so that they don't end up investigating the same person?

 

i.e. Cop go for top half and naughties go for bottom half of player list? Or vice-versa - no odds to me.

 

Yeh but they can't communicate with each other so how would they know to do this?

[Boof]

3 minutes ago, AndyNic said:

 

Yeh but they can't communicate with each other so how would they know to do this?

 

By following my suggestion.

 

Cop investigate someone in top half of player list. 2nd naughty team do whatever they're going to do to someone in the bottom half.

 

Obviously they don't have to, but it could be helpful for the town if we had a bit of an idea.

[Tenaciousdandy]

1. Stuart McNeill 18

2. Yvonnejambo 7

3. AlimOzturk 13

4. Dawnrazor 12

5. Boof 29

6. Dunks 16

7. Dr. Sheldon Cooper 8

8. Morgaro Gomis 8 

9. Bunny Munro 10

10. AndyNic 29

11. Rudi Skacel 3

12. jambosean75

13. iantjambo 6

14. milky 11

15. Riddley Walker 3

16. Smack 18

17. Marvin 16

18. Dandyman 39

 

Shapes 22

Vlad 1

• Thats the vote count, think its accurate lol 

Edited December 6, 2020 by Dandyman79

[Boof]

I accept I may be sticking my head above the parapet here but someone needs to do something otherwise we'd just get bogged down in a silent game with a flurry of last-minute voting that helps nobody. Well...nobody except the goons, maybe.

 

And possibly Shapes too  

 

If my head is above the parapet, I'd be quite happy for the goons or naughties to take a pop at me. I am utterly expendable so Cop - don't waste an investigation and Doc - don't waste a save.

[Morgaro Gomis]

Afternoon all

 

Will try and be more active today. Genuinely forgot about the game yesterday and Saturdays aren’t the best for me anyway. 

 

Don’t have much in the way of theories as yet but the vote switching at the end of yesterday did seem a bit mental so may be worth a look. 

[jambosean75]

vote riddley

[Morgaro Gomis]

14 hours ago, AlimOzturk said:

Shite to lose a mason but gained a townie  need to find those goons. 

 

2 hours ago, AlimOzturk said:

Riddley/Yvonne/Dawn sticking out as the biggest lurkers for me so far. 

 

1 hour ago, AlimOzturk said:

Forgot she was taken out by the goons. Just goes to prove I am clearly not a goon!

 

[Shapes]

45 minutes ago, Boof said:

 

I suppose I just meant that if you're a known townie now, you'll be more of a target for the folk who want to keep waters muddied.

 

 

Spoken like a forthright, straight-talkin' Aussie, perhaps?

 

 

Very altruistic - good to keep the goons thinking.

 

Maybe more clarification from @Shapes... if two factions try to kill does a Doc-save work on both of 'em?

 

 

Also - any thoughts (from anyone) on the notion of cop/naughties working together - as far as possible - so that they don't end up investigating the same person?

 

i.e. Cop go for top half and naughties go for bottom half of player list? Or vice-versa - no odds to me.

Doc save covers all attempts at kills that night 

[Tenaciousdandy]

46 minutes ago, Boof said:

 

I suppose I just meant that if you're a known townie now, you'll be more of a target for the folk who want to keep waters muddied.

 

 

Spoken like a forthright, straight-talkin' Aussie, perhaps?

 

 

Very altruistic - good to keep the goons thinking.

 

Maybe more clarification from @Shapes... if two factions try to kill does a Doc-save work on both of 'em?

 

 

Also - any thoughts (from anyone) on the notion of cop/naughties working together - as far as possible - so that they don't end up investigating the same person?

 

i.e. Cop go for top half and naughties go for bottom half of player list? Or vice-versa - no odds to me.

That could work i think altho not sure how they would be able to work together, outwith the cop getting a rough idea to narrow down bottom 9, we also have to hope that the cop isn't in the bottom part of the list and get hit by the naughty kids, but I get your thinking tho 

[Dawnrazor]

2 hours ago, Dunks said:

 

 

So let's hear you lurkers, why shouldn't we vote for you? 

I've not really had the time for this game to be fair, problems, son started back at rugby this morning, I'm grabbing a bite to eat then heading back out, I'll hopefully have more time this evening to see what's been going on.

[AndyNic]

49 minutes ago, Dandyman79 said:

1. Stuart McNeill 18

2. Yvonnejambo 7

3. AlimOzturk 13

4. Dawnrazor 12

5. Boof 29

6. Dunks 16

7. Dr. Sheldon Cooper 8

8. Morgaro Gomis 8 

9. Bunny Munro 10

10. AndyNic 29

11. Rudi Skacel 3

12. jambosean75

13. iantjambo 6

14. milky 11

15. Riddley Walker 3

16. Smack 18

17. Marvin 16

18. Dandyman 39

 

Shapes 22

Vlad 1

• Thats the vote count, think its accurate lol 

 

Ok so lowest post count is:

 

1 & 2 - Rudi and Riddley

3. Ian 

[Smack]

Sticking with Day 1 vote, and a lurker to boot. The Grinch...

 

Vote Rudi

 

[Boof]

3. AlimOzturk

4. Dawnrazor

5. Boof

6. Dunks

7. Dr. Sheldon Cooper

8. Morgaro Gomis

9. Bunny Munro

10. AndyNic

11. Rudi Skacel

12. jambosean75

13. iantjambo

14. milky_26

15. Riddley Walker

16. Smack

17. Marvin

18. Dandyman79

 

 

Let's just say, for the sake of argument, the Cop went for one of the black guys (since that's what cops seem to do) and the naughty pair went for (whether that be investigate, save or kill is their choice) someone in the red list.

 

The naughties will acquire some new information, the Cop and mason will have some information and the rest of us will know that there's someone good, naughty or bad. With this new information...will it help them narrow down guilt-lists using information they already possess?

 

The Cop/mason know someone good and the Scottish kids know someone good - the degree of goodness is unknown but there's no chance of them turning bad so they MUST be town-friendly from here on in.

 

I'm not even sure if there's any merit in any of this - just chucking some fresh ideas into the mix and seeing what folk think of 'em. If it's making the goons uncomfortable...good  

[Boof]

37 minutes ago, Dandyman79 said:

That could work i think altho not sure how they would be able to work together, outwith the cop getting a rough idea to narrow down bottom 9, we also have to hope that the cop isn't in the bottom part of the list and get hit by the naughty kids, but I get your thinking tho 

 

There's always a risk of that happening anyway.

 

It's not quite working together - more just using my suggestion to avoid a wasted night action. Mind you - even if they did both investigate the same person...neither would be sharing that with the town just yet. Cop/mason would only do so when they're about to be eliminated and naughty kid would only do so when their partner is no more.

Edited December 6, 2020 by Boof

[AlimOzturk]

53 minutes ago, Morgaro Gomis said:

 

 

 

Bit of a stretch ffs 🤦‍♂️ 

 

Hardly going to try and fool use in such an obvious manner. 

[milky_26]

Boof the issue is knowing that the cop and the naughty girls and boys have done that without alerting the goons. Also you have forgot to add what happens if the naughties either save or kill someone rather than than investigate someone

[Boof]

2 hours ago, AlimOzturk said:

Forgot she was taken out by the goons. Just goes to prove I am clearly not a goon!

 

You must confess, that is a bit of a stretch of the imagination...

[AndyNic]

Boof, what if they decide to use their assassin skills instead as they're going for the win themselves. They'd want rid of the cop...

[Smack]

6 minutes ago, Boof said:

Let's just say, for the sake of argument, the Cop went for one of the black guys (since that's what cops seem to do) 

😂 Noice