Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
Sit Rudolf Of Tynie

Best Hearts 11

Recommended Posts

Sit Rudolf Of Tynie

Whos everyones best ever team and why?

 

Gordon- season 2005/06 is quite possibly the single most consistent i have ever seen a keeper play

Weir- cracking centre half but thought he was tremendous at right bk as well

Levein- only seen tail wnd of his career but was just pure an utter class

Webby- like levein total class and makes the game look easy

Takis- without question the best full bk ive seen at tynecastle

 

JC- absolute joy to watch even though he was coming to the end of his career

Hartley- driving force in the 2006 cup winning team and dragged us through games

Guerin- maube surprising but the man was utter class and i wish wed seen him in his prime

Rudi- legend, no more needs said

 

Robbo- goalscoring GOD

Janny- i think him and robbo would have been awesome together

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Statto

Who I've seen;

 

Gordon - One of Europe's best goalkeepers in 2006.

 

McGowan Zaliukas Webster Fyssas - Would love to have seen this defence in their prime.

 

Mikoliunas Aguiar Hartley Skacel Pretty much a 2005-07 midfield, good balance.

 

Jankauskas Bednar - We've not had a great choice of forwards over the years, they were the exception.

Edited by Statto

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Gorgieshed

Geurin? Surely not, he was pony for us!

Edited by Gorgieshed

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
JamboX2

From those I watched

 

1 - Niemi - Excellent keeper.

 

2 - Neilson - like Pressley, dependable and solid

4 -Pressley - not amazing but a fantastic captain

6 -Webster - wonderful centreback

3 - Fyssas - never see his like at Tynie again

 

11 - McCann - the best Scottish winger I've seen in Maroon

5 - Brellier - the rock that our 05/06 team needed to attack

10 - Hartley - An excellent attacking midfielder

8 - Skacel - 05/06 was standout but 5-1 was his game

 

7 - Robertson - saw his last few years but always a threat.

9 - Fuller - Janny misses out for him. Wish we'd got him in on a full deal.

Edited by JamboX2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
LeeBarclay94

Gordon

 

Locke

Weir

Elvis

Fysass

 

Hartley

Cameron

Rudi

McCann

 

Robbo

Bednar

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
rudi

Niemi

 

Nielson

Levein

McClaren

Tosh

 

Flogel

Hartley

Fulton

McCann

 

Robbo

Fuller or Lee Miller (his goal scoring ratio speaks for itself)

 

Or

 

Gordon

 

Locke

McPherson

Pressley

Fysass

 

JC

Cameron

MacKay

Rudi

 

Janny

Bednar.

 

Or

 

Henry

 

Kidd

Webster

Bruno

Naysmith

 

Bannon

Brellier

Derek Ferguson

magic Johnston

 

MDV

Sandy Clark.

 

Ach,I don't know.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Alva-Jambo

Not sure how this team would work but here goes!

 

Gordon

 

Zaliukas

 

Webster

 

Glidden

 

Hartley

 

A Conn

 

D McKay

 

Rudi S

 

Fyssas

 

Bauld

 

J Robertson

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
i8hibsh

Gordon

 

Weir

Pressley

Levein

Fyssas

 

John Colquhoun

Hartley

Cameron

Skacel

 

Robertson

Jankauskas

 

Subs

 

Niemi

Webster

MacPherson

Tosh McKinlay

Fulton

Flogel

Sandy clark

De Fries

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Uncle Buck

Gordon

 

McGowan

Pressley

Webster

Fyssas

 

Aguair

Brellier

Hartley

Skacel

 

Bednar

Jankauskas

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
JamboX2

Niemi

 

Nielson

Levein

McClaren

Tosh

 

Flogel

Hartley

Fulton

McCann

 

Robbo

Fuller or Lee Miller (his goal scoring ratio speaks for itself)

 

Or

 

Gordon

 

Locke

McPherson

Pressley

Fysass

 

JC

Cameron

MacKay

Rudi

 

Janny

Bednar.

 

Or

 

Henry

 

Kidd

Webster

Bruno

Naysmith

 

Bannon

Brellier

Derek Ferguson

magic Johnston

 

MDV

Sandy Clark.

 

Ach,I don't know.

 

I keep forgetting Lee Miller! Always liked the guy. Had he played as well as he had for us at Dundee Utd or Aberdeen he'd have a few caps to his name imo. Wouldn't mind seeing him return.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
i8hibsh

I belive Hibs bext XI to be

 

Budgie

 

Sneddon

Mitchell

Hunter

Orr

 

Weir

Rae

Murray

Evans

 

Harper

Wright

 

Potent!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Uncle Buck

Gordon

 

McGowan

Pressley

Webster

Fyssas

 

Aguair

Brellier

Hartley

Skacel

 

Bednar

Jankauskas

 

Subs -

 

Niemi

Berra/Zaliukas

Wallace

Kingston

Barr

Velicka

De Vries

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
rudi

I belive Hibs bext XI to be

 

Budgie

 

Sneddon

Mitchell

Hunter

Orr

 

Weir

Rae

Murray

Evans

 

Harper

Wright

 

Potent!

Boco is a shoe in and tortolano.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Bert Le Clos

Nieimi

 

McPherson Levein Weir

 

Hartley

 

Colquhoun Cameron Skacel McCann

 

Jankauskas Robertson

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Northwich Jambo

Tortolano ??? Bit early to be on the sauce isn,t it. He was gash, dissapointed Hobo,s not chosen our hero down Gorgie way, the one and only Ally Brazil

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Super Marius

Kurskis

 

Barasa

Petric

Philabitis

 

Ivaskevicus

The Big O

Screpis

Ksnevicius

 

Klimek

Nade

Beniusis

 

 

Some real talent in that team. Many of whom "only need a run of games" or "just need a good pre-season under their belt."

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Statto

Kurskis

 

Barasa

Petric

Philabitis

 

Ivaskevicus

The Big O

Screpis

Ksnevicius

 

Klimek

Nade

Beniusis

 

 

Some real talent in that team. Many of whom "only need a run of games" or "just need a good pre-season under their belt."

 

That's horrendous.

 

Pilibaitis is an attacking midfielder.

 

 

The Ugandan Kaka left back, Pili in behind the front three. There's your team.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Super Marius

Better off with Ugandan Morris off of Only Fools & Horses!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Jambos_1874

Kurskis

 

Barasa

Petric

Philabitis

 

Ivaskevicus

The Big O

Screpis

Ksnevicius

 

Klimek

Nade

Beniusis

 

 

Some real talent in that team. Many of whom "only need a run of games" or "just need a good pre-season under their belt."

 

That team would have still won the cup final...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
iantjambo

Kurskis

 

Barasa

Petric

Philabitis

 

Ivaskevicus

The Big O

Screpis

Ksnevicius

 

Klimek

Nade

Beniusis

 

 

Some real talent in that team. Many of whom "only need a run of games" or "just need a good pre-season under their belt."

 

Did Screpis ever play a game for us.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Gregory House M.D.

Gordon



 

Webster Pressley Zaliukas

 

Karipidis Black

Hartley

Suso Skacel Fyssas

 

Jankauskas

 

Weird formation I know. :P

 

Fyssas falling to Left Back, Karipidis to RB, Skacel to LW when defending.

Edited by Robert Kelso M.D.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Valentinho

My team (4-4-2) would be:

 

Niemi

 

McPherson

McLaren

Levein

Fyssas

 

Cameron

Hartley

Skacel

McCann

 

Robertson

Jankauskis

 

Subs: Gordon, Goncalves, Zaliukas, Pressley, Brellier, Colquhoun, Ford

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Statto

How about a Scottish XI and a foreign XI?

 

Scottish;

 

Gordon

 

Neilson Pressley Webster Wallace

 

Black Barr

Templeton Hartley N.McCann

 

C.Elliot

 

Foreign;

 

Kello

 

McGowan Zaliukas Goncalves Fyssas

 

Flogel Aguiar Skacel Driver

 

Jankauskas Bednar

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest Bilel Mohsni

------------------------------------------Gordon

 

----------------McLaren----------Weir--------Levein----------Fyssas

 

----------------Colquhoun------Salvatori-----Cameron-----Skacel

 

-----------------------------------Robertson--------Fuller

 

 

Subs: Niemi, Pressley, Locke, Naysmith, Hartley, McCann, Jankauskas

 

No place for Fulton, McPherson, Flogel, McKinlay, Crabbe, Rousset, Ferguson, Webster, Suso, Zaliukas, Clarke, Aguiar, Bruno, Bannon, Allan Johnston, Ritchie, Pinilla, Bednar or DeVries... All players who I admired greatly and would want in my Hearts team under any other circumstances. :unsure:

 

I could give you a different starting XI and subs almost every time I attempt this actually. I went for Cameron and Skacel this time but any combination of Hartley/Cameron/McCann/Skacel would be devastating really! Leaving out Fulton is just bizarre, as is the exclusion of Allan Johnston. :lol:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Cruyff Turn

GK-Gordon

RB-Jardine

LB-Mckinlay

CB-Levein

CB-Weir

CM-Bannan

CM-Cameron

CM-Skacel

RW-Colquhoun

LW-McCann

ST-Robertson

 

Subs

Gk-Niemi

-Pressley

-Frail

-Hartley

-Fulton

-A.Johnston

-Clark

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
iantjambo

How about a Scottish XI and a foreign XI?

 

Scottish;

 

Gordon

 

Neilson Pressley Webster Wallace

 

Black Barr

Templeton Hartley N.McCann

 

C.Elliot

 

Foreign;

 

Kello

 

McGowan Zaliukas Goncalves Fyssas

 

Flogel Aguiar Skacel Driver

 

Jankauskas Bednar

 

Swap Niemi for Kello and Salvatori for Driver and I would agree with that.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Gregory House M.D.

Scottish XI:

 

Gordon



 

Neilson Pressley Webster Wallace

 

Templeton Black Cameron McCann

Hartley

 

Miller

 

Foreign:

 

Niemi



 

McGowan Zaliukas Goncalves Fyssas

 

Karipidis Salvatori

Suso Aguiar Skacel

 

Jankauskas

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
rudi must stay

Niemi - Gordon was great but Niemi was more reliable IMO

 

Neilson - same as Niemi when called upon he never let us down

Webster

Pressley - Zaluikas is great, but those two as a combination, on their day, could stop anyone putting the ball in the net

Naysmith - my favorite ever Hearts player, when he went forward he could create things singlehandedly

 

Cameron - I know he usually played as a central midfielder, but I can't think of anyone, in my time watching Hearts, that's stood out in this position

Brellier - I liked Mrowiec alot, so I was tempted to put him in, but unlike JB he didn't seem to perform in the bigger matches

Hartley

Skacel - both probably don't need an explanation

 

Fuller - I wish I could say he wasn't the best striker i'd seen, but that goal against Motherwell summed him up as a player. I've never seen anyone since, in a maroon shirt, score a goal like that

Velicka - for me, this guys a legend. Adam and Bednar were great, but they didn't scored with the ease Velicka did

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Statto

Scottish XI:

 

Gordon



 

Neilson Pressley Webster Wallace

 

Templeton Black Cameron McCann

Hartley

 

Miller

 

Foreign:

 

Niemi



 

McGowan Zaliukas Goncalves Fyssas

 

Karipidis Salvatori

Suso Aguiar Skacel

 

Jankauskas

 

I forgot about Lee Miller, I put Calum Elliot in :vrface:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
i8hibsh

Boco is a shoe in and tortolano.

 

 

Jimmy Boco!!!! Oh my sides I forgot about him hahahahaha.

 

2008060508315616.jpg

 

Bizarrely wiki have him as a defender and a goalkeeper.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
i8hibsh

Jimmy Boco!!!! Oh my sides I forgot about him hahahahaha.

 

2008060508315616.jpg

 

Bizarrely wiki have him as a defender and a goalkeeper.

 

 

Also, did Tortolano ever get his Italian cap? lol

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
SRC HMFC

 

 

 

I forgot about Lee Miller, I put Calum Elliot in :vrface:

Craig Beattie surely ahead of them both.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Statto

Craig Beattie surely ahead of them both.

 

Beattie only played about 6 games.

 

John Robertson would be in if I'd seen him play.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
SRC HMFC

 

 

 

Beattie only played about 6 games.

 

John Robertson would be in if I'd seen him play.

Miller played about 15, Beattie certainly did more for us in his time here and most had forgotten what it was like to have a real striker. Also like you if I'd seen enough of Robertson he'd be a certainty.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Mikey1874

Gordon

Patterson, Levein, Jardine, Naysmith

Brellier, Hartley, Bannon

Robertson, Colquhoun, Skacel

 

Subs: Niemi, Webster, Weir, Cameron, Jankauskus, Prentice, Clark

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Seed1874

'Guid Scottish Laddies' XI

Gordon

Neilson Elvis Webster Naysmith

Colquhoun Hartley Cameron McCann

Robbo Crabbe

 

manager Jim Jefferies

 

Johhny Foreigner XI

Kello

Gowser Zaliukas Bruno Takis

Miko Aguiar Rudi

Fuller Jankauskas Adam

 

manager Paulo Sergio

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Bert Le Clos

There are some absolutely disgusting shouts on this thread :lol:

 

Robbie Neilson in an all time greatest Hearts XI?! :vrface:

 

He's not even the best RB since he played for Hearts FFS.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Maroon Sailor

Gordon

 

Kidd

Jardine

Levein

McKinlay

 

Colquhoun

Cameron

Skacel

Mackay

 

Robertson

Clark

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Gregory House M.D.

 

 

 

Craig Beattie surely ahead of them both.

 

Lee Miller scored one of the best goals I've seen for Hearts and was on fire for us. Beattie never played nearly enough to beat that for me.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Seed1874

There are some absolutely disgusting shouts on this thread :lol:

 

Robbie Neilson in an all time greatest Hearts XI?! :vrface:

 

He's not even the best RB since he played for Hearts FFS.

 

Aye yer right, how dare people form their opinions on the 'all time greatest XI'. Surely everyone MUST choose the all conquering team from the 50s from now on as they were universally known as the 'all time greatest Hearts XI'?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Special Agent Dale Cooper

Niemi

 

McPherson Weir Ritchie Fyssas

 

Colquhoun Hartley Fulton Cameron Skacel

 

Robertson

Edited by mikethejambo

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Bert Le Clos

Aye yer right, how dare people form their opinions on the 'all time greatest XI'. Surely everyone MUST choose the all conquering team from the 50s from now on as they were universally known as the 'all time greatest Hearts XI'?

 

:lol:

 

I've not seen anyone saying an XI from the 50's should automatically qualify as the greatest Hearts XI. What I have seen however, are many, many better right backs than Robbie Neilson play for Hearts.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
winston churchill

Niemi

 

Shaggy Frail Jardine Levein Naysmith

 

Colquhoun Cameron Hartley McCann

 

Robertson Clark

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Seed1874

:lol:

 

I've not seen anyone saying an XI from the 50's should automatically qualify as the greatest Hearts XI. What I have seen however, are many, many better right backs than Robbie Neilson play for Hearts.

Opinions my man, opinions. Would be shite if everybody agreed. My inclusion of Robbie was taking into consideration the years service he provided for us and he was never the worst, could have easily opted for Lockey or Frail but (in my opinion) I chose Robbie. Just out of interest if you have seen many, many better right backs than Robbie, bearing in mind that he was in the Scottish XI - name 5.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Uncle Buck

Niemi

 

Shaggy Frail Jardine Levein Naysmith

 

Colquhoun Cameron Hartley McCann

 

Robertson Clark

 

Possibly your best ever post on Kickback.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Bert Le Clos

Opinions my man, opinions. Would be shite if everybody agreed. My inclusion of Robbie was taking into consideration the years service he provided for us and he was never the worst, could have easily opted for Lockey or Frail but (in my opinion) I chose Robbie. Just out of interest if you have seen many, many better right backs than Robbie, bearing in mind that he was in the Scottish XI - name 5.

 

McLaren, Weir, McPherson, Frail, Locke

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Seed1874

McLaren, Weir, McPherson, Frail, Locke

Never seen McLaren play hence why I didn't mention him, certainly never seen Weir at rb and personally wouldn't have McPherson in my XI. And thats what the OP requested, peoples all time greatest Hearts team, fair enough you dont agree with my Neilson pick, I dont agree with your McPherson pick, thats life. Like I said before it would be shite if we all agreed on the same.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
jbee647

 

Not sure how this team would work but here goes!

 

Gordon

 

Zaliukas

 

Webster

 

Glidden

 

Hartley

 

A Conn

 

D McKay

 

Rudi S

 

Fyssas

 

Bauld

 

J Robertson

 

 

Freddie Glidden, sorry but you must be related to the guy, ok a legend for being the cup winning captain in 1956, but was only in the side because first choice captain Bobby Parker was injured, guys like Alan Anderson Levein McPherson David Weir and Stephen Pressley were far far better players than Glidden, and that's no disrespect to the guy, but he wasn't even an automatic choice for Hearts for a long spell, in fact he had left the club shortly after the 1958 championship win

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Bert Le Clos

Never seen McLaren play hence why I didn't mention him, certainly never seen Weir at rb and personally wouldn't have McPherson in my XI. And thats what the OP requested, peoples all time greatest Hearts team, fair enough you dont agree with my Neilson pick, I dont agree with your McPherson pick, thats life. Like I said before it would be shite if we all agreed on the same.

 

Calm down Robbie, it's nothing against you personally :cool4:

 

Mc Laren was outstanding, fair enough if you never saw him play. Weir regularly played right back for us before moving to centre half. McPherson won 20 odd caps for Scotland his performances for us earned him a transfer to Rangers helped them win a treble and a double in two seasons. To be honest my comment wasn't mainly directed at you, as you say you picked Neilson in a all Scottish XI (still wrong mind), but some people had him in their greatest ever side, which I just don't get.

 

The whole argument of not picking players in an all time team because you never saw them play doesn't always wash. It would be like asking people to pick an all time greatest team and leaving out Pele and Maradona. How anyone cannot pick Robbo is beyond me to be honest, regardless of whether they saw him play or not. FFS someone has Lee Miller ahead of him.

Edited by Bert Le Clos

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
cosanostra

Have we ever had a quality right back?

Gowser and Maybury were both good for us but nor really all that special.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  

×